Gosh, you guys have no idea how close you've got to the actual answer.
Remember,
I wrote: Think more along the lines of word play.
Adam/
re'born, of my 2 elaborated questions, you've got one of them right. Not to say the other was totally wrong, but there're other alternative answers and you haven't picked the correct one.
Cec wrote:Udosuk, speaking for myself, whilst I have some understanding of baseball, I think one would have to have a fairly good grasp of the rules, jargon, etc. to come up with an answer to this riddle.
Not really. I'd say anybody who loosely follow the sport can answer this riddle. You just need to know a certain term (which is often mentioned in baseball-related news on TV & newspaper) and also how fielding positions are abbrieviated (as displayed in all televised baseball games).
That said, I won't be surprised if Australian/British sport fans who only know about cricket and never pay any attention to baseball can't solve this riddle at all.
Lastly, I must say if somebody took his time to read through all the posts above carefully, he might realise the answer which has somehow escaped from his eyes!