I'm sure this will be very helpful to mith when he starts dealing with the T&E(2) collection. I'll also start to have a look at it.
Paquita wrote:Is it generally true that T&E(3) puzzles are not hard?
No. You can ask the same question about puzzles containing a full quad (4 candidates in each of the 4 cells). Such puzzles may be in T&E(2). But if you know the Quad pattern, they become much easier to solve, in general.
All the known patterns in T&E(3) have a tridagon with more or less guardians. If you know the tridagon pattern
and rules able to use it, you can simplify the puzzle. In most cases, it doesn't become easy at all.
The existence of T&E(3) puzzles and the use of the T&E-depth criterion have been a breakthrough in the search of "hard" puzzles. They raise questions of their own that SER is unable to tackle.
Paquita wrote:Mith has done such a lot to collect T&E(3) puzzles that I thought I would focus on T&E(2), it is now a much smaller collection. But given that I have sometimes used T&E(3) puzzles as seeds, I do end up with some T&E(3) puzzles as well. I will post them seperately.
It has become clear that the two collections have separate search criteria and separate goals: T&E-depth vs highest SER (or PGX).
None of the two collections can claim to have the goal of finding "the hardest puzzles", because this expression is meaningless if you don't say hardest wrt what.
The T&E(2) collection is currently smaller because mith's technique of expansion hasn't been systematically applied to it.
After a closer look, there's still something wrong in your collection: it lacks a uniform presentation.
- you should use either a semi-colon or a space as separator, but not both. (semi-colon is much better IMO).
- for ER EP ED, you should use either 3 fields ER;EP;ED or one ER/EP/ED, but the choice should be the same everywhere (empty fields would appear as ;; )
- for ER, EP or ED, use the same notation everywhere: either 11.9 or 11.90, not both.
- a first line should name the fields, e.g.: puzzle; orig-puzzle; ER; EP; ED; collection, creator; name; nb_in_collection; ?;
(what does "1;22;" or "11523;23;" means at the end of the 1st two lines?
.