The New Sudoku Players' Forum

Sponsored by Enjoy Sudoku

Skip to content

The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Everything about Sudoku that doesn't fit in one of the other sections
Post a reply

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby hendrik_monard » Fri Dec 20, 2024 5:59 pm

denis_berthier wrote:
hendrik_monard wrote:Here is a batch of 196 new B7B+ puzzles representing the same number of new solutions. This brings the total number of different solutions in my B7B+ database to 799.

Hi Hendrik
It's very interesting that you could enlarge the database of solution grids having B7B+ puzzles (all of which, except 3 old B7B ones, have a non-degenerate tridagon until now).
I'm curious about the number of minimal B7B+ puzzles you've got so far from these 799 grids. Could you publish them also?
.

Since last summer, I have focused on finding new solution grids. I adapted my scripts accordingly. We have earlier observed that once you have a B7B+ puzzle, minimal or expanded to a certain degree, in many cases an important number of related minimals can be obtained with the same BxB rating by a process of subsequent expanding and 'minimalisation' rounds.
However, given my limited resources, I prefer to concentrate them on identifying new B7B+ grids. Minimalisation plays a role in this process, as does twinning. I have not the intention to list all possible minimals obtainable with the exp/min/exp/min...process. However, as the 196 new puzzles in my post of yesterday are probably all min_expands, it should not be difficult to derive the minimals of these puzzles. Perhaps I'm wrong, but I think that Paquita and coloin posted already lists of minimals of previously posted B7B puzzles.
hendrik_monard
 
Posts: 107
Joined: 19 April 2021
Location: Leuven (Louvain) Belgium
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby coloin » Fri Dec 20, 2024 8:20 pm

Many of the twins were already there in some form....which is probably to be expected as your search process is thorough !
In adding clues to your puzzles to expand to max BxB there were BxB 6s found ...
I think I generated many BxB 6 and looked for higher by minimizing and rexpanding with singles.

I took the liberty of adding the BxB7 11.9 to the puzzles section to see what the solvers thought of it !!

The 11.9s are derived from fully expanded 11.6s
BxB10
Code: Select all
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2#10# #8 #ED=11.9/11.9/2.6 #       
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2#10# #8 #ED=11.9/11.9/2.6 #       
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2#10# #8 #ED=11.9/11.9/2.6 #       
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2#10# #8 #ED=11.9/11.9/2.6 #       
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4...#10# #8 #ED=11.9/11.9/2.6 #       
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4...#10# #8 #ED=11.9/11.9/2.6 #       
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7......75.9....9.6..1...#10# #8 #ED=11.9/11.9/2.6 #   

adding 2 more clues and the Bxb is still 10 but SE is 11.6
Code: Select all
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96..32....149.6...3.2#10#ED=11.6/11.6/2.6               
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69..32....149.6...3.2#10#ED=11.6/11.6/2.6               
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96..32....149.6...3.2#10#ED=11.6/11.6/2.6               
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69..32....149.6...3.2#10#ED=11.6/11.6/2.6               
.2345....45...9...6.9.23...235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4...#10#ED=11.6/11.6/2.6               
.2345....45...9...6.9.23...235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4...#10#ED=11.6/11.6/2.6               
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7.5....75.9....9.6..1...#10#ED=11.6/11.6/2.6               
.2....78.4.7...2.6.68....5428.7..46..746..5.86.58...27....1.......5.3......2...45#10#ED=11.6/11.6/2.6 

BxB 7
Code: Select all
.23.5....45...9...6.92.....2.6...4..........7.....26.134..259...659.43..9.263.5..# 7#3# ED=11.9/11.9/2.6           
...4...89....8.23......31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...482..93..8.314.2# 7#3# ED=11.9/11.9/2.6           
...4...89....8.23......31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...483..92..8.214.3# 7#3# ED=11.9/11.9/2.6

adding 1 more clue and the BxB is still 7 but 6 more twins are found
Code: Select all
.2345....45...9...6.92.3...2.6...4..........7.....26.134..259...659.43..9.263.5..# 7#9# ED=11.6/11.6/2.6           
...4...89....8923....2.31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...482..93..8.314.2# 7#9# ED=11.6/11.6/2.6           
...4...89....8923....2.31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...483..92..8.214.3# 7#9# ED=11.6/11.6/2.6           
12..56.8..5718....6.87.2.1.27.56...88.52.1.....6.78......627.51...............9.3# 7#9# ED=11.6/11.6/2.6           
...4.678.....89.36...73...4.6.9.3.47.3..6789..7.84.6.3.95.....8.4..98.....2......# 7#9# ED=11.6/11.6/2.6           
1......89...18..3.........423..78.6..8162..7.7.63.1.2.3..7.2...67.81.....12.63...# 7#9# ED=11.6/11.6/2.6           
.234.6...4.678...378..32..4...............95....6784.23.284......7.63...86.2.73..# 7#9# ED=11.6/11.6/2.6           
...4.678.....89.36...73...4.6.9.7.43.7..6389..3.84.6.7.95.....8.4..98.....2......# 7#9# ED=11.6/11.6/2.6           
1......89...18..3.........42.63.1.7..8167..2.73..28.6.3..7.2...67.81.....12.63...# 7#9# ED=11.6/11.6/2.6 

omly 3 of the 9 twins reduce to a 11.9

Here are the expanded puzzles and 34 new twin puzzles ....
Hidden Text: Show
Code: Select all
..34.6...4.718..36....73....41.683.....7.4...7.631.8....4....28.7....495...84.1.3 #13# 2#  6008 FNBP C34/M2.123.10
..34.6...4.718..36....73....46.183.....7.4...7.136.8....4....28.7....495...84.1.3 #13# 2#  6008 FNBP C34/M2.123.10
                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                                 
.2345...945.7.9...7.9.23..4...5.7.........6....7....1537.2.4.....293.....94.7523. #10# 6# 95554 FNBP C33/M2.33.198
1.345..8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.51...8.43.38...9.19.4..385. #10# 6# 95554 FNBP C33/M2.33.198
1.345..8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.53...8.41.18...9.39.4..385. #10# 6# 95554 FNBP C33/M2.33.198
12..56.89.5....26.6.9...1.52.1...9.8.659...1289.2..65.......8.1.1.84.........7... #10# 6# 95539 FNBP C33/M2.33.198
12...6.894.6..91.2.89...64...4.7........9.21...83.....6.....4.18.2....96.41.6.82. #10# 6# 95539 FNBP C33/M2.33.198
12..5.78..57...2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.28.165.81.....2..65...1.8 #10# 6# 95539 FNBP C33/M2.33.198
1.3.56....5.18....68.2.3...21.56.8..3.8.216...653.81......32.........3.4.3.....7. #10# 7# 95533 FNBP C32/M2.17.385
..345.7.9...7.913...9.13.54.3.1.457.....359.1....7..433.....415.6.......8........ #10# 7# 95530 FNBP C32/M2.17.385
.2345...945..89...8.92.3..4238....4........1.......6..3.45.....58..324...928.4... #10# 7# 95530 FNBP C32/M2.17.385
1.3..67.9.57..9.3669...315....8.7...7...4...........753.....61..61....9797....5.3 #10# 7# 95528 FNBP C32/M2.17.385
.2.45..89.5..8923..9.2.35.4.36............4.37...3........9..58...32.94....5.83.2 #10# 7# 95523 FNBP C32/M2.17.385
1.3..67.9.57..9.3696...315....8.7...7...4...........753.....91..91....6767....5.3 #10# 7# 95523 FNBP C32/M2.17.385
1.34...8945....13..891..5.4..5....4883...495.9.4...3.1....6.........7.......4.893 #10# 7# 95523 FNBP C32/M2.17.385
.2345....45...9...6.93.25.4......8...36...........3.613.4.95.2.56.2.4.9..9263.... #10# 3# 95320 FNBP C33/M2.37.177
.23...7.945...9.327.9..354.2.....35.3.4....97.75.3.2.4..7.1........9.4.5..26..... #10# 3# 95315 FNBP C33/M2.37.177
12..5.78..57...2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.58.162.81.....5..62...8.1 #10# 3# 95301 FNBP C33/M2.37.177
.2345....45...9...6.93.2.........8...36...........3.613.2.95.4.56.2.4.9..9463..2. #10# 7# 65492 FNBP C32/M2.56.117
.2.45.7.9.5.7.9.32....2354....3..9.5..5.9437....57..24..2...497..1......8........ #10# 7# 65062 FNBP C32/M2.56.117
1.3.56.8..5718..3.68.3.7....18.6....3.587....76.5.1..8571.....3......4..........2 #10# 7# 64754 FNBP C32/M2.56.117
...4.6.89..6.891.2..921.64.....9.8.1....4296.9..8.1.245........6.....218.3....... #10# 8# 64275 FNBP C32/M2.60.109
....5678..5.18..36.8.7.31.52..........5...361..4.........61.5.8...8...73..8.3761. #10# 7# 63890 FNBP C32/M2.56.117
.234.6.8.4.678..2.78..23.6.2.8.7....34.86.....673.2....34..........3.94.........5 #10# 8# 62811 FNBP C32/M2.60.109
1.3.567...5718....68.3.71.....86357.........2.......9.37.5.1...5.863...7.6..78... #10# 5# 31750 FNBP C33/M2.97.67
12..56....57.8...66.8..7...2.57..1...618.2...78..15.2........9.......3.....5218.7 #10# 1# 31019 FNBP C31/M2.75.87
1.3...7.9.571...3696.3..15..35....9161......77.9..156.....2....57691.........4... #10# 5# 30992 FNBP C33/M2.97.67
12.4.6.8.4.6.89....8921..4.2.196...8.68..2...94.1.8...........3612...89.......5.. #10# 5# 30818 FNBP C33/M2.97.67
12..567...571.92..6.927.1..2.56.1....1679.....7..25.........6.3...96.5...6.....4. #10# 4# 30348 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
1.3.56.8..5678..3.78.1.3......561.78......4..........2.156.78..6..81....8.7.35... #10# 5# 30337 FNBP C33/M2.97.67
1.3.56.8..5678..3.78.1.3......561.78......4..........2.176.58..6..81....8.5.37... #10# 5# 30337 FNBP C33/M2.97.67
12.4...894.6...1.2.892..64..18..49.664.....289.....41....64.891....3.........7... #10# 4# 30116 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..73.58...5..31....8.16.7.4.........2......8.1...573 #10# 4# 29845 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
1.3..67.9.57..9.3696...751..7....65.6.5....91.91...3.7.1..4.......8.1........51.3 #10# 4# 29706 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
1.3.5.78..57.8..3686....1.5.......7338.5.76.1.7....85....21.........4.......65318 #10# 4#  7988 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
1.3.5.78..57.8..6386..7.1.5....643.....2..6...8671....61....83.7.8...5...35...... #10# 4#  7905 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
..3.567.9..71.9.36..637.15.2.1.....5.6971.....4......1...9.15.7...53........67..3 #10# 4#  7787 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
..3.567.9..71.9.36..937.15.2.1.....5.9671.....4......1...6.15.7....97..3...53.... #10# 4#  7770 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....79..5....3.5...5..97.14.7..5.49.39...13.75 #10# 5#  6712 FNBP C34/M2.106.61
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....79..5....5.3...5..97.14.7..3.49.59...15.73 #10# 5#  6712 FNBP C34/M2.106.61
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....97..5....3.5...5..79.14.7..5.49.39...13.75 #10# 5#  6712 FNBP C34/M2.106.61
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....97..5....5.3...5..79.14.7..3.49.59...15.73 #10# 5#  6712 FNBP C34/M2.106.61
12....78..571..2.66.82...152.1...5...65......78..2.16....6.3...8167.2......84.6.. #10# 5#  6712 FNBP C34/M2.106.61
...45.7.94..7.9.237...3254..6.......3.....95.5.1..........7439....29..75...3..4.2 #10# 5#  4274 FNBP C31/M2.78.84
...45.7.94..7.9.237...3254..6.......3.....95.5.1..........9437....27..95...3..4.2 #10# 5#  4274 FNBP C31/M2.78.84
......7.9.......3..89.....62.1.68..4.649.2..189.14.....186.4...64..2....9.281.... #10# 5#  4272 FNBP C31/M2.78.84
......7.9.......3..89.....62.4.68..1.619.2..489.14.....186.4...64..2....9.281.... #10# 5#  4272 FNBP C31/M2.78.84
.....6......78.....89.3.....94...31.31......58.5...9.45.1.4..93.38.1.45.94....8.1 #10# 5#  4271 FNBP C31/M2.78.84
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7.5....75.9....9.6..1... #10# 8#  3106 FNBP C31/M2.26.252
12..56..9.571.9..66.927...527.96.....167.5...9.5..2.........8.7.....7.4.7.1.....2 #10# 2#  2797 FNBP C33/M2.51.128
1..4.678.4..18..368...731.4.9.7.....3.....6.77.5..........41.73...3..8.1...8.746. #10# 2#  2791 FNBP C33/M2.51.128
.2....78.4.7...2.6.68....5428.7..46..746..5.86.58...27....1.......5.3......2...45 #10# 8#  1919 FNBP C32/M2.59.111
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 #10# 8#  1908 FNBP C32/M2.59.111
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69..32....149.6...3.2 #10# 8#  1908 FNBP C32/M2.59.111
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 #10# 8#  1908 FNBP C32/M2.59.111
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69..32....149.6...3.2 #10# 8#  1908 FNBP C32/M2.59.111
.2345....45...9...6.9.23...235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... #10# 8#  1908 FNBP C32/M2.59.111
.2345....45...9...6.9.23...235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... #10# 8#  1908 FNBP C32/M2.59.111
1.3.5.78..57.8..3668....1.5.18....5737....61.5.6.....373186.......9..........4... #10# 5#  1898 FNBP C32/M2.58.113
....5.......1.9236...7.....29....4.13.1..462..64..1.93.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 #10# 5#  1895 FNBP C32/M2.58.113
....5.......1.9236...7.....29....4.13.4..162..61..4.93.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 #10# 5#  1895 FNBP C32/M2.58.113
1..4.678.4..18..366...731.4.9.......7.5......8..3.7......61...8...7.43.1....3864. #10# 5#  1892 FNBP C32/M2.58.113
12..56..9.571.9..66.927...1.......4.......8.7...7.2..55...91....6152....9.26.7... #10# 5#  1892 FNBP C32/M2.58.113
12....78..57...2.66.8....15...7..........356....64.12..1.2..85....8...7178.5..6.2 #10# 2#  1286 FNBP C32/M1.1.54 
1.3.567.9...1.9.366.973.51......719........57....156.3..4......8........97.563... #10# 2#  1064 FNBP C32/M1.1.54 
1.3.56....5718....68.7.3......6.5.41...8.19..........773.51...8....67..3.6.3.8..5 #10# 1#  1048 FNBP C32/M1.1.54 
1.3.56..9.571.9..369.37...1...6..8.7.......2.7.6.....537.96.....65.13...9.15..... #10# 2#  1014 FNBP C33/M2.85.77
....56..9.5.1.926....32..5123.961....7.........4......3..51.69.5...931.2...6.2.35 #10# 2#  1013 FNBP C33/M2.85.77
.23.5..8945..8.23.9.8...5.423....8...49...3.58.5....42.94.2.......6.........974.. #10# 2#  1013 FNBP C32/M2.38.172
.234...8945....23.9.83..5.42.5...39.34....8.2.89....4.5.28........51..2......7... #10# 2#   990 FNBP C32/M2.38.172
...4.67..4..18.2.6....72....96.......48621...5.1...6.....81.4.2..42.7.61..2.6487. #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72 
..3.567.9..71.9.36...73.51..31975....49......8.5....9.3..51.97.....93.6....6.7... #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72 
1...567.9...1.9.369..37.15....7..5.1..19.5.63......97.31....69558.......6.45..... #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72 
1.3.56.8..5718..3.68.7.3.1..15...863.....5..2......95.3.1..8...56..71..8.78...... #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72 
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...23.6..49..14...6.39.63...2139.......6.2...9...41.6.3.2 #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72 
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...23.6..49..41...6.39.63...2139.......6.2...9...14.6.3.2 #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72 
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.1439....79..5....5.3...5..34.97.7..9.51.39...71.45 #10# 4#   726 FNBP C34/M1.3.43 
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.1439....79..5....5.3...5..37.94.7..9.51.39...41.75 #10# 4#   726 FNBP C34/M1.3.43 
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.1439....97..5....5.3...5..34.97.7...91.459..7.51.3 #10# 4#   726 FNBP C34/M1.3.43 
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....79..5....5.3...5..37.94.7..9.51.39...14.75 #10# 4#   726 FNBP C34/M1.3.43 
..34.6...4.7.89...68.73.....6894....3.4.679..97.3.84.....67389.........5.......2. #10# 1#   577 FNBP C32/M1.2.39 
.2..567.9.5.7.9.23.9.23.56..7....3.6.64......8...........9.36.2...5..97.....27.35 #10# 3#   482 FNBP C32/M1.2.39 
....56...45..8.......2......14....9853....1.49.8...3..3.5.1.94..41.9.8.389..3..15 #10# 3#   411 FNBP C32/M1.2.39 
....5..89...18.........3...2.5.4.96..94.6.8.286..2..45..2...5.454....69.9.6....28 #10# 3#   405 FNBP C32/M1.2.39 
1.3.....945.....36.69..341..4.....535...3.9.493....16....7.....614.95........2... #10# 1#   316 FNBP C30/M1.2.50 
...4.67....7..9.......2.....98....7151....9..7.6...85..71..859.86...51.79.5..1.68 #10# 2#   303 FNBP C32/M1.2.52 
...4.67....7..9.......2.....98....7151....9..7.6...85..75..819.86...15.79.1..5.68 #10# 2#   303 FNBP C32/M1.2.52 
12..567...567.91..7.921.6..2.71.5...69..72....15.6........2.94.........39.2...5.. #10# 2#   300 FNBP C33/M1.2.54 
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.....1....53.9........5.8..334....92..75...3.49.2.....7 #10# 2#   278 FNBP C33/M1.2.54 
                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                                 
12..56....57.8...66.8..7...2.57..1...618.2...78..15.2.....218.7......39.......... # 9# 1# 96186 FNBP C30/M2.28.234
...4.6.....7.89.36...37..4...1......37..98...8.5....6....9.76.87..83..949...6437. # 9# 4# 95023 FNBP C32/M2.39.168
...4.6.....7.89.36...37..4...1......37..98...8.5....6....9.76.87...6439.9..83..74 # 9# 4# 95018 FNBP C32/M2.39.168
...4.6.....7.89.63...37...4..1......37..98...9.5.....6...8.769.7...643.88..93..47 # 9# 4# 95018 FNBP C32/M2.39.168
.23.....94.7..9.3669..........8.1..47.4.62.......4....34..7.9.2.72...36.9.6.2..47 # 9# 4# 95011 FNBP C32/M2.39.168
12....7.9.5.1..26.6......5127..9.6.5..6..7.929.5...17.....4.........8...7926.5... # 9# 1# 33629 FNBP C31/M2.73.89
12....78..5.1..2.66......1527...865.8.6...1.7..5.7..28.....4.......9....78256.... # 9# 1# 33438 FNBP C31/M2.73.89
12..56....57.8...66.8..7.........3.........9....5218.7.618.2...5.27..1..78..15.2. # 9# 1# 33112 FNBP C31/M2.74.88
12....7.9.5.1..26.6......5127..9.5.6..6..7.929.5...17.....4.........8...7926.5... # 9# 1# 32878 FNBP C31/M2.74.88
12....78..5.1..2.66......1527...856.8.6...1.7..5.7..28.....4.......9....78256.... # 9# 1# 32691 FNBP C31/M2.74.88
12..56....57.8...66.8..7..........9.......3.....5218.7.618.2...5.27..1..87..15.2. # 9# 1# 32364 FNBP C31/M2.73.89
1.3.567...5718....68.3.71..........4365...8.1.......2.51..3....7.6.18....386.5.1. # 9# 2# 30947 FNBP C33/M2.98.66
.2345...945...9...6.9.32...24.39..6.3.5.64.9..962.5...534...92.......8..........7 # 9# 4# 30709 FNBP C33/M2.98.66
12.4.6.8.4.6.89....8921..4.29..614...6482......19.4...........7...192.64......3.. # 9# 2# 30614 FNBP C33/M2.98.66
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8....1527.8...61.81...5.2..6...87.....18627.....4......3..... # 9# 9# 30589 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
12.4.6...4.6.891...8921.6..2.1.68....489.2..19..14...........5....89421.........7 # 9# 9# 30471 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
12..567...571.92..6.972.1..2.56.1....7629.....1..75.........6.3...96.5...6.....4. # 9# 9# 30353 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
.23.5.......1..2......27...24.....566.5...9...39...42.36..4.59.5.4.9.6.2.92.6..34 # 9# 9# 30311 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
1.3.56....5718...668.3.7..1......9.........2.738....653.587.6..81.6.5....76..3... # 9# 4# 30147 FNBP C33/M2.98.66
...4.678.....89.36...73...428.........5.....8.4..98....7..6389..6.9.7.43.3.84.6.7 # 9# 9# 29821 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
1.3.5.7.9.57....3669..7.51..697..1.353....97.7.1....6....8..........4...916.37... # 9# 9# 29537 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.4.75.9..9582..7.87.9.4.2..48.97...7.254....9..2.8... # 9# 4# 29434 FNBP C33/M2.98.66
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.8.75.9..4592..7.79.8.4.2..74.98...8..2.7...9.254.... # 9# 9# 29180 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
...45..8.4.......6......14.29.8.4.7..4597..2.7.8.25.9..74.98...8..2.7...9.254.... # 9# 9# 29180 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
...45..8.4.......6......14.2..9.8....98.74...7.452.....7589..2.84.2.7.9.9.2.45.7. # 9# 4# 28759 FNBP C33/M2.98.66
...45..8.4.......6......14.2..8.7....78.94...9.452.....9524..7.74.9.8.2.8.2.75.9. # 9# 9# 28731 FNBP C33/M2.94.69
1.3..6....571.9.3.69.3...1...19.3..773..15...9.576.1.3........4......8.....59736. # 9# 4#  8459 FNBP C33/M2.42.156
...4.678.4...8.2.668..72.54....485....876.4.2..42.5..83.........1........45...627 # 9# 4#  8217 FNBP C33/M2.42.156
12..56..9.57..9..66.9.7....2.57.169..6192....9...651.....512.67......3.........4. # 9# 4#  8210 FNBP C33/M2.42.156
..3.567.9..71.9.36..6...15.2.9...5...4....9.7..1.95......51.67.....63.9....9.73.5 # 9# 4#  8182 FNBP C33/M2.42.156
12.4..78.4.71..2.6.682...142.6814......6.5.......9..6..12....4.68..4..277.4...... # 9# 3#  6897 FNBP C34/M2.107.61
..3.567.9..71.9.36...73.15.2.6......3.5671....81....6....9.7.......63.9..3.51.67. # 9# 3#  6895 FNBP C34/M2.107.61
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...27.6.1..4.64.78..28.124.......714.287.....3.1.......57 # 9# 1#  6804 FNBP C34/M2.105.62
1.3..67.9.57..9.3669...351..6....39.......6.773..6..51...8.1......6951.3.1..4.... # 9# 3#  6495 FNBP C34/M2.107.61
..3.5678...718..36...3.71.524.....5.395....1.7.853........7..6..7.6........81.57. # 9# 2#  3132 FNBP C33/M1.1.70 
1.3.56....5718...668.3.7..5.1....593.3....42....53.6.836.81.....7.6.........7..6. # 9# 2#  3132 FNBP C33/M1.1.70 
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.457.....98.24...7..9.8....7589..2.84.2.7.9.9.2.45.7. # 9# 1#  2363 FNBP C33/M2.107.61
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.8.95.7..7524..9.94.8.7.2..94.28...7..9.4...8.257.... # 9# 2#  2363 FNBP C33/M2.107.61
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.857.....94.28...7..9.4....7524..9.8.2.95.7.94.8.7.2. # 9# 2#  2363 FNBP C33/M2.107.61
12..567.9.57...26.6.9.72.15.....8...5619.7.......3.......7..19.71....5.6.9.....27 # 9# 1#  2284 FNBP C33/M1.1.53 
..345..89....8923...92.34.5.6.........4....287.8..2......92..43.....459.....358.2 # 9# 5#  1987 FNBP C32/M2.20.328
..345..89....8923...92.34.5.6.........4....287.8..2......93..42.....459.....258.3 # 9# 5#  1987 FNBP C32/M2.20.328
1.3.56.8..5718....68.3.7.5....6.381.......9..........23..5.1...57..68....6173.5.. # 9# 5#  1982 FNBP C32/M2.20.328
....567.9.5.1.9.36.9.73.15.26..7......8.......1.....67...5.7.91....9367.....1.3.5 # 9# 5#  1978 FNBP C32/M2.20.328
1.3.56.8..5718....68.3.7.5....6.351.......9..........23..8.1....6173.8..87..65... # 9# 5#  1978 FNBP C32/M2.20.328
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..73.58...5..31....8.16.7.42...............86....573 # 8# 4#  1390 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..38.57...5..81....7.16.336....578..2.......4....... # 9# 6#  1213 FNBP C33/M2.72.91
.234.6...4.678...278..23..623..68....7834.6..6.4..7.........9..847...2.3.......1. # 9# 6#  1208 FNBP C33/M2.72.91
.2345.7..45.7.9...7.9.325..23..94.7..4537....9.72.....392...45........1.........6 # 9# 6#  1202 FNBP C33/M2.72.91
.23....894.....2.38.9...41.2.8..4.3139...28.4.41..892......319....6.....9...71... # 9# 6#  1200 FNBP C33/M2.72.91
12..56..9.567.9..27.921....21.5.....6.5.71.2..976.2.........8..561....97.......4. # 9# 6#  1200 FNBP C33/M2.72.91
.23.5.78.45..8..237.8...5.4234.78......9..........1...3.2..5.4754....3...87...25. # 9# 6#  1199 FNBP C33/M2.72.91
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....825..61.5.1...9.896.8...25 # 8# 1#  1000 FNBP C33/M1.2.40 
12..56....5718...66.82.7..5.7.....91......3.7...7615.2.8.6.5...76..12.5....87.... # 9# 1#   750 FNBP C34/M2.89.73
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...27.6.8..4.61.74..28.421...........977.....3.1...741.28 # 9# 4#   734 FNBP C34/M2.90.72
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...27.6.8..4.64.71..28.124...........977.....3.1...714.28 # 9# 4#   734 FNBP C34/M2.90.72
1.34.6...45.18.....68.3........1.5.7.......2.5.1...3..6.5.418...345.86..81.36.4.. # 9# 5#   303 FNBP C33/M1.2.54 
1.3.56....5718....68.3.71.........9.........2768...5.35.687...183.6.1....71..5... # 9# 2#   302 FNBP C32/M1.2.53 
.2.45..89.5..8923..8.3.24.5.31.....47.........9..4.......9.5..2...82.94.....34.58 # 9# 2#   299 FNBP C32/M1.2.53 
12.4.6.8.4.6.89.2..9821..6.2.48......61.24...98.6.1....19....4.......3.....1...95 # 9# 5#   297 FNBP C33/M1.2.54 
.2.45..89.5..8912..8.1.25.4.4....91.61..9......7.........5.849.....4.2.8...92..51 # 9# 5#   271 FNBP C33/M1.2.54 
.2.45..89.5..8912..8.1.25.4.4....91.61..9......7.........9.845.....4.2.8...52..91 # 9# 5#   271 FNBP C33/M1.2.54 
....56.89...1.92.6....2.51...596.8.1..15.862...6.12.95..2...9.87.8.9.....3....... # 9# 5#   267 FNBP C33/M1.2.54 
                                                                                                                 
1.3...789.......23....3..45.15.97..83.981...778.5.3...5.1....7..78......93..758.. # 8# 1# 95036 FNBP C34/M2.46.710
123...7.9.56..9....89......2..6.739........27.7....6.1...96.27...72.3.16..2.719.3 # 8# 1# 92250 FNBP C34/M2.59.111
..3.5678...718..36...7.35.12.........78.31...9.1....5.3...18.757..6.5......37..6. # 8# 1# 89387 FNBP C33/M2.38.172
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.573..5.....5..318.......24375 # 8# 4#  1880 FNBP C36/M1.1.62 
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.573..518...5..3.........24375 # 8# 4#  1880 FNBP C36/M1.1.62 
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.753..5.....5..318.......24357 # 8# 4#  1880 FNBP C36/M1.1.62 
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.753..518...5..3.........24357 # 8# 4#  1880 FNBP C36/M1.1.62 
.23.5.78.45..8..237.8...5.4237.48......9.1............3.4..5.7257....3...82...45. # 8# 4#  1389 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
1.3....8945.....3..89...4.5.14..8.533.8..49.159...384....6.1.9....7.....9.1..5... # 8# 4#  1389 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
1.3....8945.....3..89...4.5.18..4.533.4..89.159...384....6.1.9....7.....9.1..5... # 8# 4#  1389 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
1.3..67.9.57..9.3669....15........737.....96.93.7..5.13....5...5.924.......6.1.95 # 8# 3#  1383 FNBP C34/M1.1.41 
1.3.5.7.9.57....3669..7.15..657.1.93..1...57....5..6.1..629........379.5...8..... # 8# 3#  1383 FNBP C34/M1.1.41 
1.34.6.......8........235...14...9..63.94.1.59.5.1....3.1..469.56....4.1.49..1.53 # 8# 3#  1383 FNBP C34/M1.1.41 
...45........89.....92.7.4.2...48.955..92.4.79..7.582..95872...71.......86.....7. # 8# 2#   483 FNBP C33/M1.1.52 
...45........89.....92.7.4.2..7.589.5..92.4.79...48.25.95872...71.......86.....7. # 8# 2#   483 FNBP C33/M1.1.52 
                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                                 
1..45.7.94..7.913.....13.54....719.....94..73..73.5.1.3.2......5.8...3.....53.... # 7# 3# 97055 FNBP C32/M2.11.178
1.3.5....45.1.9....983...1..4591.3..3.98.4...81..354........97.....9.82.98....... # 7# 3# 96986 FNBP C32/M2.11.178
....5678.4.....23...........1.86......4.158..58.7.4...7.15.8...86..41..7.4567...8 # 7# 3# 96975 FNBP C32/M2.11.178
.23...7.945...923.7.9..3.452.4...39..75.9.4.29......57..2..........3.5.4..761.... # 7# 3# 96806 FNBP C33/M2.19.345
.23.5..8945..8.23.8.9...5.428.....4..35...89.9.4..83.23.2..5......7.14........9.. # 7# 3# 96730 FNBP C33/M2.19.345
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8....15..69.3......8...72..1.......6....5.77.25...61.15...82. # 7# 3# 96641 FNBP C33/M2.19.345
1...56....5.18...668.3.7.....1.38.7.3.567....87.5.13...........73.....51......42. # 7# 1# 95751 FNBP C30/M2.24.273
1...56....5.18...668.7.3.....5.38.7.3.167....87.5.13...........73.....15......42. # 7# 1# 95751 FNBP C30/M2.23.285
1.3.56....57.8...668...7....167.3...53.8...1.7.8.153.................92.....31.78 # 7# 1# 95734 FNBP C30/M2.24.273
1..4.678.4..18..638...371.4...64..17...8.34.6....718..3.5...6....2.........36.... # 7# 7# 95159 FNBP C32/M2.50.524
.2.45.7.9.5.7.9.32....2354....5..9.4..5.9437....37..25..2...497.........8.1...... # 7# 7# 95158 FNBP C32/M2.50.524
1.3.56.8..5718..3.68.3.7....18.7....3.586....76.5.1..8571.....3......4.2......... # 7# 7# 95156 FNBP C32/M2.50.524
1.3...78..57...2.3.8.....51...6......3.9.2.........32.37...15.85.2..713..18..5.72 # 7# 7# 95153 FNBP C32/M2.50.524
1.3.567...5718.3..68.3.7.....1.75......8.1...8.563...7........2..8...6.4...76.53. # 7# 2# 95024 FNBP C32/M2.39.168
.23.....94.7..9.3669..........8.1..77.4.62.......4....34..7.9.2.72...36.9.6.2..74 # 7# 2# 95011 FNBP C32/M2.39.168
12..56....57.8...66.8..7...2.5.7.1...618.2...78..15.2.......39.............5218.7 # 7# 1# 54506 FNBP C31/M2.52.126
.234.6...4.678...378..32..4...............95....6784.23.284......7.63...86.2.73.. # 7# 9#  1399 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
.2345....45...9...6.92.3...2.6...4..........7.....26.134..259...659.43..9.263.5.. # 7# 9#  1390 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
12..56.8..5718....6.87.2.1.27.56...88.52.1.....6.78......627.51...............9.3 # 7# 9#  1390 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
...4.678.....89.36...73...4.6.9.3.47.3..6789..7.84.6.3.95.....8.4..98.....2...... # 7# 9#  1390 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
...4.678.....89.36...73...4.6.9.7.43.7..6389..3.84.6.7.95.....8.4..98.....2...... # 7# 9#  1390 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
1......89...18..3.........423..78.6..8162..7.7.63.1.2.3..7.2...67.81.....12.63... # 7# 9#  1388 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
1......89...18..3.........42.63.1.7..8167..2.73..28.6.3..7.2...67.81.....12.63... # 7# 9#  1388 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
...4...89....8923....2.31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...483..92..8.214.3 # 7# 9#  1382 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
...4...89....8923....2.31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...482..93..8.314.2 # 7# 9#  1382 FNBP C33/M1.1.51 
1.....7.9...18923.......4.12.189...3.952.3..883..15..23...2....51.93.82....5..3.. # 7# 2#   649 FNBP C35/M1.1.63 
1.....7.9...18923.......4.12.589...3.912.3..883..15..23...2....51.93.82....5..3.. # 7# 2#   649 FNBP C35/M1.1.63 
1.....7.9...18923.......4.123..15..8.918.3..28.529...33...2....51.93.82....5..3.. # 7# 2#   649 FNBP C35/M1.1.63 
1.....7.9...18923.......4.123..15..8.958.3..28.129...33...2....51.93.82....5..3.. # 7# 2#   649 FNBP C35/M1.1.63 
                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                                 
NEW TWINS                                                                                                         
.2345...945.7.9..37.9.23..4...5.7.........6....7....1537.2.4.....293.....94.75... #10# 8# 66740 FNBP C32/M2.60.109
12.....89.5....26.6.9...1.52.15..9.8.659...1289.2..65.......8.1.1.84.........7... #10# 8# 62038 FNBP C32/M2.60.109
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.2...65.81.....2..65...1.8 #10# 8# 60741 FNBP C32/M2.60.109
1.3....8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.53...8.41.18..49.39.4..385. #10# 8# 61356 FNBP C32/M2.60.109
1.3....8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.51...8.43.38..49.19.4..385. #10# 8# 61356 FNBP C32/M2.60.109
12...6.894.6..91.2.89...64.....7........9.214...3.....6.....4.18.2....96.41.6.82. #10# 8# 61478 FNBP C32/M2.60.109
.23...7.945...9.327.9..354.2.....35.3.4....97.75.3.2.4....1........9.475...6..... #10# 7# 63936 FNBP C32/M2.56.117
.2345....45...9...6.93.2.........8...36...........3.613.4.95.2.56.2.4.9..9263..4. #10# 7# 65492 FNBP C32/M2.56.117
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.5...62.81.....5..62...8.1 #10# 7# 60849 FNBP C32/M2.56.117
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69...2....149.6...3.2 #10# 8#  3118 FNBP C31/M2.26.252
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69...2....149.6...3.2 #10# 8#  3118 FNBP C31/M2.26.252
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96...2....149.6...3.2 #10# 8#  3118 FNBP C31/M2.26.252
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96...2....149.6...3.2 #10# 8#  3118 FNBP C31/M2.26.252
.2....78.4.....2.6.68....5428.7..46..746..5.86.58...27....1.......5.3......2...45 #10# 8#  3118 FNBP C31/M2.26.252
.2345....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... #10# 8#  3106 FNBP C31/M2.26.252
.2345....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... #10# 8#  3106 FNBP C31/M2.26.252
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7.5....75.9....9.6.31... #10# 8#  1904 FNBP C32/M2.59.111
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...2.481.....61.72..487.6.4..2.......977.....3.1...741.28 #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
...4.67..4..18.2.6....27....96.......48261...5.1...6.....81.4.2..46.2.71..2.7486. #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...2.481.....61.74..287.6.2..4.......977.....3.1...741.28 #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
...4.67..4..18.2.6....27....96.......48261...5.1...6.....81.4.2..26.4.71..4.7286. #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
...4.6...4.718.2..6...72...2.481.....61.27..487.6.4..2.......977.....3.1...741.28 #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...2.63...9139.6..42..14...6.36.2...9...41.6.3.293....... #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...2.184.....64.71..287.6.2..4.......977.....3.1...714.28 #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...2.6...9..39........14.6.3.2.41...6.36.23...9193.6..42. #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
...4.67..4..18.2.6....72....96.......48261...5.1...6.....81.4.2..26.4.71..4.2786. #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
..3.567.9..71.9.36...73.51.2.6......3.5...671.81.6..........9.7....9..63.3.67.15. #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
..3.567.9..71.9.36..937.51.2.6.......4....6..9756.3.......379.....9.1....9.56.3.1 #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8.2..1521........85.....27.6..21.8...97....87.265........4..7 #10#18#   734 FNBP C34/M2.91.72
....567.9.5.1.9.63.9.37.51.27...3....34.......69...375.......51.....193.9...356.7 # 9# 4#   734 FNBP C34/M2.90.72
.23....8.45..8..366.8.........9.4...3.4825.......7..4.5.6..23.8.32..8.5484...362. # 9# 4#   734 FNBP C34/M2.90.72
.23.5..8945..8.23.8.9...5.428.....4..35...89.9.4..83.2342..5......7.1............ # 7# 7# 95161 FNBP C32/M2.50.524
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8....15...9.3......8..672..........6....5.77.25...61.15...82. # 7# 7# 95134 FNBP C32/M2.50.524
.23...7.945...923.7.9..3.452.4...39..75.9.4.29......57.............3.574...61.... # 7# 7# 95156 FNBP C32/M2.50.524


And here is a link to all the minimal puzzles BXB-Mastermmin4
coloin
 
Posts: 2515
Joined: 05 May 2005
Location: Devon
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby denis_berthier » Sat Dec 21, 2024 4:43 am

hendrik_monard wrote:Since last summer, I have focused on finding new solution grids. I adapted my scripts accordingly. We have earlier observed that once you have a B7B+ puzzle, minimal or expanded to a certain degree, in many cases an important number of related minimals can be obtained with the same BxB rating by a process of subsequent expanding and 'minimalisation' rounds.

Until now, the search for hard puzzles has explored only a very small part of the space of solution grids. Finding new solution grids having B7B+ puzzles is a very interesting (and new) goal.
.
denis_berthier
2010 Supporter
 
Posts: 4275
Joined: 19 June 2007
Location: Paris
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby denis_berthier » Sat Dec 21, 2024 4:44 am

coloin wrote:And here is a link to all the minimal puzzles BXB-Mastermmin4


It requires an authorisation.
denis_berthier
2010 Supporter
 
Posts: 4275
Joined: 19 June 2007
Location: Paris
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby hendrik_monard » Sat Dec 21, 2024 10:20 am

coloin wrote:Many of the twins were already there in some form....which is probably to be expected as your search process is thorough !
In adding clues to your puzzles to expand to max BxB there were BxB 6s found ...
I think I generated many BxB 6 and looked for higher by minimizing and rexpanding with singles.

I took the liberty of adding the BxB7 11.9 to the puzzles section to see what the solvers thought of it !!

Very interesting analysis indeed, also about the effect of advanced expansions on SER and BxB.
It is noticeable that we now also find more SER 11.9s. BTW, in my previous post I counted 11 11.9s, but two of them were counted twice. I changed the number in my post of yesterday.
In your results there are also two new solutions! I will add them to my B7B+ solutions database:
Code: Select all
123456789457189263698372514271563498534798126869214375346927851785641932912835647   9   241220   ....567.9.5.1.9.63.9.37.51.27...3....34.......69...375.......51.....193.9...356.7   col   
123456789457189236698237415281964573374825961965371842516742398732698154849513627   9   241220   .23....8.45..8..366.8.........9.4...3.4825.......7..4.5.6..23.8.32..8.5484...362.   col   

I also found two cases of different BxB rating within the BXB7+ domain for the same solution.
Code: Select all
123456789457189236698327145214673958786592314935841627342765891571938462869214573
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..73.58...5..31....8.16.7.42...............86....573   9   coloin   241220
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..7..58...5..31......16.7.42...............86....573   8   monh   241219

123456789457189236698723154239645871746218593815937462382594617571362948964871325
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....825..61.5.1...9.896.8...25   9   coloin   241220
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....82...61.5.1...9.896.8...25   8   monh  2412219

This seems to happen rather exceptionally. While setting up the B7B+ solutions database I only noticed a few such cases.
This must be the result from 'higher' expansions.
hendrik_monard
 
Posts: 107
Joined: 19 April 2021
Location: Leuven (Louvain) Belgium
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby coloin » Sat Dec 21, 2024 2:46 pm

hendrik_monard wrote:BTW, in my previous post I counted 11 11.9s, but two of them were counted twice. I changed the number in my post of yesterday.

Yes you found 9 of them but actually the twins of the BxB7 added two more [8+3] you had the 11.6 version of the 2 other puzzles !
hendrik_monard wrote:In your results there are also two new solutions! I will add them to my B7B+ solutions database:

I would have expected that all new twin puzzles would be new solution grids ...?
hendrik_monard wrote:I also found two cases of different BxB rating within the BXB7+ domain for the same solution.

I think all these puzzles are BxB 8 ... so possibly a typo [ Usually SHC is consistent]

I have altered the approvals for all the files..
coloin
 
Posts: 2515
Joined: 05 May 2005
Location: Devon
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby coloin » Sat Dec 21, 2024 2:53 pm

BXB-Mastermins
BXB-Mastermins2
BXB-Mastermins3
BXB-Mastermins4
coloin
 
Posts: 2515
Joined: 05 May 2005
Location: Devon
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby denis_berthier » Sat Dec 21, 2024 3:38 pm

coloin wrote:
hendrik_monard wrote:I also found two cases of different BxB rating within the BXB7+ domain for the same solution.

I think all these puzzles are BxB 8 ... so possibly a typo [ Usually SHC is consistent]

I think what Hendrik means is, for some solution grid, there are different non-isomorphic B7B+ puzzles with different BxB ratings - which is to be expected.
What I find more surprising is, this seems to be rare. Hendrik, can you say more about this ?
.
denis_berthier
2010 Supporter
 
Posts: 4275
Joined: 19 June 2007
Location: Paris
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby denis_berthier » Sat Dec 21, 2024 3:44 pm



So, in order to have all the minimal B7B+ found until now, one has to add the 4 files ?
.
denis_berthier
2010 Supporter
 
Posts: 4275
Joined: 19 June 2007
Location: Paris
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby denis_berthier » Sat Dec 21, 2024 4:22 pm

hendrik_monard wrote:I also found two cases of different BxB rating within the BXB7+ domain for the same solution.
Code: Select all
123456789457189236698327145214673958786592314935841627342765891571938462869214573
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..73.58...5..31....8.16.7.42...............86....573   9   coloin   241220
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..7..58...5..31......16.7.42...............86....573   8   monh   241219

123456789457189236698723154239645871746218593815937462382594617571362948964871325
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....825..61.5.1...9.896.8...25   9   coloin   241220
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....82...61.5.1...9.896.8...25   8   monh  2412219
.


There's an error or a typo: the 4 BxB classifs are 8.
.
denis_berthier
2010 Supporter
 
Posts: 4275
Joined: 19 June 2007
Location: Paris
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby hendrik_monard » Sun Dec 22, 2024 3:14 pm

coloin wrote:]
I would have expected that all new twin puzzles would be new solution grids ...?
.

Hi coloin,
I also expected more new solution grids. That there are so few can perhaps be explained by the fact that I already applied the twinning process to puzzles produced by my generating scripts. Anyway, I checked my results again and added some instructions to produce the following list of duplicates. Among them are (towards the end of the list) also 12 duplicates with puzzles in your list of October 15th.
After adding the two new solutions from your list, the new total of B7B+ solution grids becomes 801.
Hidden Text: Show
This list can best be interpreted when copied to a textfile.

123456789457189236689723145271534698395268471864971523548312967732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145274531698395268471861974523548312967732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145271534968395268471864971523548312697732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145274531968395268471861974523548312697732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723154235971468874632591961548372312865947548297613796314825
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... monh 241219
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... col 241220

123456789457189236689723154235971468874632591961548372312895647548267913796314825
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... monh 241219
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... col 241220

123456789457189236698372154269547813531928647784613925312765498875294361946831572
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7......75.9....9.6..1... monh 241219
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7......75.9....9.6..1... col 241220

123456789457189236689723145271534698395268471864971523548312967732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145271534968395268471864971523548312697732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145274531698395268471861974523548312967732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145274531968395268471861974523548312697732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723154235971468874632591961548372312865947548297613796314825
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.9.23...235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... col 241220

123456789457189236689723154235971468874632591961548372312895647548267913796314825
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.9.23...235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... col 241220

123456789457189236698372154269547813531928647784613925312765498875294361946831572
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7......75.9....9.6..1... monh 241219
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7.5....75.9....9.6..1... col 241220

123456789457189236968372154289735461374621598615894327542918673796543812831267945
.2....78.4.....2.6..8....5428.7..46..746..5.86.58...27....1.......5.3......2...45 monh 241219
.2....78.4.7...2.6.68....5428.7..46..746..5.86.58...27....1.......5.3......2...45 col 241220

123456789457189236689273145216897453594361827738542691341725968865914372972638514
.23.5....45...9...6.92.....2.6...4..........7.....26.134..259...659.43..9.263.5.. monh 241219
.23.5....45...9...6.92.....2.6...4..........7.....26.134..259...659.43..9.263.5.. col 241220

123456789457189236896273154289745361641398527735612948372964815514827693968531472
...4...89....8923......31.4..9.....16.13.....7..........29.481...482..93..8.314.2 monh 241219
...4...89....8.23......31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...482..93..8.314.2 col 241220

123456789457189236896273154289745361641398527735612948372964815514837692968521473
...4...89....8923......31.4..9.....16.13.....7..........29.481...483..92..8.214.3 monh 241219
...4...89....8.23......31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...483..92..8.214.3 col 241220

123456789457189236689273145216897453594361827738542691341725968865914372972638514
.23.5....45...9...6.92.....2.6...4..........7.....26.134..259...659.43..9.263.5.. monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.92.3...2.6...4..........7.....26.134..259...659.43..9.263.5.. col 241220

123456789457189236896273154289745361641398527735612948372964815514827693968531472
...4...89....8923......31.4..9.....16.13.....7..........29.481...482..93..8.314.2 monh 241219
...4...89....8923....2.31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...482..93..8.314.2 col 241220

123456789457189236896273154289745361641398527735612948372964815514837692968521473
...4...89....8923......31.4..9.....16.13.....7..........29.481...483..92..8.214.3 monh 241219
...4...89....8923....2.31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...483..92..8.214.3 col 241220

123456789457189236698732514271564398835291647946378125389627451564913872712845963
12..56.8..5718....6.87.2.1.27.56...88..2.1.....6.78......627.51...............9.3 monh 241219
12..56.8..5718....6.87.2.1.27.56...88.52.1.....6.78......627.51...............9.3 col 241220

123456789457189236689732154268913547534267891971845623395621478746598312812374965
...4.678.....89.3....73...4.6.9.3.47.3..6789..7.84.6.3.95.....8.4..98.....2...... monh 241219
...4.678.....89.36...73...4.6.9.3.47.3..6789..7.84.6.3.95.....8.4..98.....2...... col 241220

123456789457189236968237154239578461581624973746391825395742618674815392812963547
1......89...18..3.........423..78.6..8162..7.7.63.1.2.3..7.2....7.81.....12.63... monh 241219
1......89...18..3.........423..78.6..8162..7.7.63.1.2.3..7.2...67.81.....12.63... col 241220

123456789456789123789132564271594836648321957935678412392845671517963248864217395
.234.6...4.678...378..32..4...............95....6784.23..84......7.63...86.2.73.. monh 241219
.234.6...4.678...378..32..4...............95....6784.23.284......7.63...86.2.73.. col 241220

123456789457189236689732154268917543574263891931845627395621478746598312812374965
...4.678.....89.3....73...4.6.9.7.43.7..6389..3.84.6.7.95.....8.4..98.....2...... monh 241219
...4.678.....89.36...73...4.6.9.7.43.7..6389..3.84.6.7.95.....8.4..98.....2...... col 241220

123456789457189236968237154246391875581674923739528461395742618674815392812963547
1......89...18..3.........42.63.1.7..8167..2.73..28.6.3..7.2....7.81.....12.63... monh 241219
1......89...18..3.........42.63.1.7..8167..2.73..28.6.3..7.2...67.81.....12.63... col 241220

123456789457189236689273514241968357538724961796315842314597628872631495965842173
..34.6...4.718...6....7.....41.683.....7.4...7.631.8.........28.7.....95...84.1.. monh 241219
..34.6...4.718..36....73....41.683.....7.4...7.631.8....4....28.7....495...84.1.3 col 241220

123456789457189236689273514246918357538724961791365842314597628872631495965842173
..34.6...4.718...6....7.....46.183.....7.4...7.136.8.........28.7.....95...84.1.. monh 241219
..34.6...4.718..36....73....46.183.....7.4...7.136.8....4....28.7....495...84.1.3 col 241220

123456789456789123789123564231567948548391672967842315375214896612938457894675231
.2345...945.7.9...7.9.23..4...5.7.........6....7....1537.2.4.....293.....94.752.. monh 241219
.2345...945.7.9...7.9.23..4...5.7.........6....7....1537.2.4.....293.....94.7523. col 241220

123456789457189236689372415291837564346925178875641392512798643738564921964213857
1.3.5..8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.51...8.43.38...9.19.4..385. monh 241219
1.345..8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.51...8.43.38...9.19.4..385. col 241220

123456789457189236689372415291837564346925178875641392532798641718564923964213857
1.3.5..8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.53...8.41.18...9.39.4..385. monh 241219
1.345..8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.53...8.41.18...9.39.4..385. col 241220

123456789457189263689723145271564938365978412894231657546392871712845396938617524
12...6.89.5....26.6.9...1.52.1...9.8.659...1289.2..65.......8.1.1.84.........7... monh 241219
12..56.89.5....26.6.9...1.52.1...9.8.659...1289.2..65.......8.1.1.84.........7... col 241220

123456789456789132789213645294671358367895214518342967635928471872134596941567823
12...6.894.6..91.2.89...64.....7........9.21...83.....6.....4.18.2....96.41.6.82. monh 241219
12...6.894.6..91.2.89...64...4.7........9.21...83.....6.....4.18.2....96.41.6.82. col 241220

123456789457189236698327415289613547376542891541978362732891654814765923965234178
12..5.78..57...2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.2..165.81.....2..65...1.8 monh 241219
12..5.78..57...2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.28.165.81.....2..65...1.8 col 241220

123456789457189236689273451214567893378921645965348127546732918792815364831694572
1.3.56....5.1.....68.2.3...21.56.8..3.8.216...653.81......32.........3.4.3.....7. monh 241219
1.3.56....5.18....68.2.3...21.56.8..3.8.216...653.81......32.........3.4.3.....7. col 241220

123456789456789132789213654238194576647835921915672843372968415561347298894521367
..3.5.7.9...7.913...9.13.54.3.1.457.....359.1....7..433.....415.6.......8........ monh 241219
..345.7.9...7.913...9.13.54.3.1.457.....359.1....7..433.....415.6.......8........ col 241220

123456789457189236869273154238691547645728913971345628314567892586932471792814365
.2345...945...9...8.92.3..4238....4........1.......6..3.45.....58..324...928.4... monh 241219
.2345...945..89...8.92.3..4238....4........1.......6..3.45.....58..324...928.4... col 241220

123456789457189236698723154245897361736541928819362475384975612561234897972618543
1.3..67.9.57..9.3669...315....8.7.......4............53......1..61....9797....5.3 monh 241219
1.3..67.9.57..9.3669...315....8.7...7...4...........753.....61..61....9797....5.3 col 241220

123456789457189236698273514236714895519862473784935621342697158865321947971548362
.2.45..89.5..8923..9.2.35.4.36............4..7............9...8...32.94....5.83.2 monh 241219
.2.45..89.5..8923..9.2.35.4.36............4.37...3........9..58...32.94....5.83.2 col 241220

123456789457189236968723154245867391739541628816392475384675912591234867672918543
1.3..67.9.57..9.3696...315....8.7.......4............53......1..91....6767....5.3 monh 241219
1.3..67.9.57..9.3696...315....8.7...7...4...........753.....91..91....6767....5.3 col 241220

123456789456789132789132564275913648831624957964578321392861475548397216617245893
1.34...8945....13...91..5.4..5....4883...495.9.4...3.1....6.........7.......4.893 monh 241219
1.34...8945....13..891..5.4..5....4883...495.9.4...3.1....6.........7.......4.893 col 241220

123456789457189236689372514241967853836541972975823461314795628568214397792638145
.2345....45...9...6.93.25........8...36...........3.613.4.95.2.56.2.4.9..9263.... monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.93.25.4......8...36...........3.613.4.95.2.56.2.4.9..9263.... col 241220

123456789456789132789123546268947351314562897975831264597314628631298475842675913
.23...7.945...9.327.9..354.2.....35.3.4....97.75.3.2.4..7.1........9.4.5..26..... monh 241219
.23...7.945...9.327.9..354.2.....35.3.4....97.75.3.2.4..7.1........9.4.5..26..... col 241220

123456789457189236698327415289613547376245198541978362735891624814762953962534871
12..5.78..57...2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.5..162.81.....5..62...8.1 monh 241219
12..5.78..57...2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.58.162.81.....5..62...8.1 col 241220

123456789457189236689372514241967853836541972975823461312795648568214397794638125
.2345....45...9...6.93.2.........8...36...........3.613.2.95.4.56.2.4.9..9463..2. monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.93.2.........8...36...........3.613.2.95.4.56.2.4.9..9463..2. col 241220

123456789456789132789123546247368915615294378938571624362815497571942863894637251
.2.45.7.9.5.7.9.32....2354....3..9.5..5.9437....57..24..2...497..1......8........ monh 241219
.2.45.7.9.5.7.9.32....2354....3..9.5..5.9437....57..24..2...497..1......8........ col 241220

123456789457189236689327541218964375395872164764531928571248693832695417946713852
1.3.56.8..5718..3.68.3.7....18.6....3.587....76.5.1..8571.....3......4..........2 monh 241219
1.3.56.8..5718..3.68.3.7....18.6....3.587....76.5.1..8571.....3......4..........2 col 241220

123456789456789132789213645264397851318542967975861324591628473647935218832174596
...4.6.89..6.891.2..921.64.....9.8.1....4296.9..8.1.245........6.....218.3....... monh 241219
...4.6.89..6.891.2..921.64.....9.8.1....4296.9..8.1.245........6.....218.3....... col 241220

123456789457189236689723145236971854795248361814365927372614598561892473948537612
....5678..5.18..36.8.7.31.52..........5...361..4.........61.5.8...8...73..8.3761. monh 241219
....5678..5.18..36.8.7.31.52..........5...361..4.........61.5.8...8...73..8.3761. col 241220

123456789456789123789123564218975436345861297967342851534297618671538942892614375
.234.6.8.4.678..2.78..23.6.2.8.7....34.86.....673.2....34..........3.94.........5 monh 241219
.234.6.8.4.678..2.78..23.6.2.8.7....34.86.....673.2....34..........3.94.........5 col 241220

123456789457189236689327145291863574736945812845712693372591468518634927964278351
1...567...5718....68.3.71.....86357.........2.......9.37.5.1...5.863...7.6..78... monh 241219
1.3.567...5718....68.3.71.....86357.........2.......9.37.5.1...5.863...7.6..78... col 241220

123456789457189236698237514245793168361842975789615423514378692872964351936521847
12..56....57.8...66.8..7...2.57..1...618.2....8..15.2........9.......3......218.7 monh 241219
12..56....57.8...66.8..7...2.57..1...618.2...78..15.2........9.......3.....5218.7 col 241220

123456789457189236968372154235867491614593827789241563341625978576918342892734615
1.3...7.9.571...3696.3..15..35....9161......77.9..15......2....57691.........4... monh 241219
1.3...7.9.571...3696.3..15..35....9161......77.9..156.....2....57691.........4... col 241220

123456789456789132789213645271964358368572914945138276597821463612345897834697521
12.4.6...4.6.89....892...4.2.196...8.68..2...94.1.8...........3612....9.......5.. monh 241219
12.4.6.8.4.6.89....8921..4.2.196...8.68..2...94.1.8...........3612...89.......5.. col 241220

123456789457189236689273154295641378316798425874325961542817693738964512961532847
12..567...571.92..6.927.1..2.56.1....1679.....7...5.........6.3...96.5...6.....4. monh 241219
12..567...571.92..6.927.1..2.56.1....1679.....7..25.........6.3...96.5...6.....4. col 241220

123456789456789231789123645234561978568972413971348562315697824692814357847235196
1.3.56.....678..3.78.1.3......561.7.......4..........2.156.78..6..81....8.7.35... monh 241219
1.3.56.8..5678..3.78.1.3......561.78......4..........2.156.78..6..81....8.7.35... col 241220

123456789456789231789123645234561978568972413971348562317695824692814357845237196
1.3.56.....678..3.78.1.3......561.7.......4..........2.176.58..6..81....8.5.37... monh 241219
1.3.56.8..5678..3.78.1.3......561.78......4..........2.176.58..6..81....8.5.37... col 241220

123456789456789132789213645218374956647591328935862417372645891561938274894127563
12.4...894.6...1.2.8.2..64..18..49.664.....289.....41....64.891....3.........7... monh 241219
12.4...894.6...1.2.892..64..18..49.664.....289.....41....64.891....3.........7... col 241220

123456789457189236689327145214673958768592314935841627346715892572938461891264573
1....678....18..366..3.71.5.1..73.58...5..31....8.16.7.4.........2......8.1...573 monh 241219
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..73.58...5..31....8.16.7.4.........2......8.1...573 col 241220

123456789457189236968327514274913658635278491891564327319742865546831972782695143
1.3..67.9.57..9.3696...751..7.....5.6.5....91.91...3.7.1..4.......8.1........51.3 monh 241219
1.3..67.9.57..9.3696...751..7....65.6.5....91.91...3.7.1..4.......8.1........51.3 col 241220

123456789457189236869732145215648973384597621976321854598213467631874592742965318
1.3.5.78..57.8..3686....1.5.......7338...76.1.7....85....21.........4.......65318 monh 241219
1.3.5.78..57.8..3686....1.5.......7338.5.76.1.7....85....21.........4.......65318 col 241220

123456789457189263869372145291564378374298651586713924612945837748631592935827416
1.3.5.78..57.8..6386..7.1.5....643.....2......8671....61....83.7.8...5...35...... monh 241219
1.3.5.78..57.8..6386..7.1.5....643.....2..6...8671....61....83.7.8...5...35...... col 241220

123456789457189236896372154231894675569713428748625391382941567674538912915267843
..3.567.9..71.9.36..637.15.2.1.....5.6971.....4......1...9.15.7...53........67..3 monh 241219
..3.567.9..71.9.36..637.15.2.1.....5.6971.....4......1...9.15.7...53........67..3 col 241220

123456789457189236869372154231864975596713428748925361382641597615297843974538612
..3.567.9..71.9.36..937.15.2.1.....5.9671.....4..........6.15.7....97..3...53.... monh 241219
..3.567.9..71.9.36..937.15.2.1.....5.9671.....4......1...6.15.7....97..3...53.... col 241220

123456789457189236698237514265841397314792658879365421536978142781524963942613875
12.......4.71.9.....8....1...5.4139....79..5....3.5...5..97.14.7..5.49.39...13.75 monh 241219
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....79..5....3.5...5..97.14.7..5.49.39...13.75 col 241220

123456789457189236698237514265841397314792658879563421536978142781324965942615873
12.......4.71.9.....8....1...5.4139....79..5....5.3...5..97.14.7..3.49.59...15.73 monh 241219
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....79..5....5.3...5..97.14.7..3.49.59...15.73 col 241220

123456789457189236698237514265841397314972658879365421536798142781524963942613875
12.......4.71.9.....8....1...5.4139....97..5....3.5...5..79.14.7..5.49.39...13.75 monh 241219
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....97..5....3.5...5..79.14.7..5.49.39...13.75 col 241220

123456789457189236698237514265841397314972658879563421536798142781324965942615873
12.......4.71.9.....8....1...5.4139....97..5....5.3...5..79.14.7..3.49.59...15.73 monh 241219
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....97..5....5.3...5..79.14.7..3.49.59...15.73 col 241220

123456789457189236698237415241368597365971842789524163574613928816792354932845671
12....78..571..2.66.82...1.2.1...5...65......78....16....6.3...8167.2......84.6.. monh 241219
12....78..571..2.66.82...152.1...5...65......78..2.16....6.3...8167.2......84.6.. col 241220

123456789456789123789132546267915834348627951591843267612574398834291675975368412
...45.7.94..7.9.237...3254..6.......3.....95.5.1..........7439....29...5...3..4.2 monh 241219
...45.7.94..7.9.237...3254..6.......3.....95.5.1..........7439....29..75...3..4.2 col 241220

123456789456789123789132546267915834348627951591843267612594378834271695975368412
...45.7.94..7.9.237...3254..6.......3.....95.5.1..........9437....27..95...3..4.2 monh 241219
...45.7.94..7.9.237...3254..6.......3.....95.5.1..........9437....27..95...3..4.2 col 241220

123456789456789132789231546271568394364972851895143627518694273647325918932817465
......7.9.......3..89.....62.1.68..4.649.2..189.14.....186.4...64..2....9.281.... monh 241219
......7.9.......3..89.....62.1.68..4.649.2..189.14.....186.4...64..2....9.281.... col 241220

123456789456789132789231546274568391361972854895143627518694273647325918932817465
......7.9.......3..89.....62.4.68..1.619.2..489.14.....186.4...64..2....9.281.... monh 241219
......7.9.......3..89.....62.4.68..1.619.2..489.14.....186.4...64..2....9.281.... col 241220

123456789456789132789231546294567318317894625865123974571648293638912457942375861
.....6......78.....89.3.....94...31.31......58.5...9.45.1.4..93.38.1.45.94....8.1 monh 241219
.....6......78.....89.3.....94...31.31......58.5...9.45.1.4..93.38.1.45.94....8.1 col 241220

123456789457189236698372154269547813531928647784613925312765498875294361946831572
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7......75.9....9.6..1... monh 241219
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7.5....75.9....9.6..1... col 241220

123456789457189236689273415274961358816735924935842671362514897598627143741398562
12..56..9.571.9..66.927...527.96.....1.7.....9.5..2.........8.7.....7.4.7.1.....2 monh 241219
12..56..9.571.9..66.927...527.96.....167.5...9.5..2.........8.7.....7.4.7.1.....2 col 241220

123456789457189236869273154296734518348512697715968342582641973674395821931827465
1..4.678.4..18..368...731.4.9.7.....3.....6.77.5..........41.73...3..8.1.....7.6. monh 241219
1..4.678.4..18..368...731.4.9.7.....3.....6.77.5..........41.73...3..8.1...8.746. col 241220

123456789457189236968372154289735461374621598615894327542918673796543812831267945
.2....78.4.....2.6..8....5428.7..46..746..5.86.58...27....1.......5.3......2...45 monh 241219
.2....78.4.7...2.6.68....5428.7..46..746..5.86.58...27....1.......5.3......2...45 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145271534698395268471864971523548312967732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145271534968395268471864971523548312697732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145274531698395268471861974523548312967732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145274531968395268471861974523548312697732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723154235971468874632591961548372312865947548297613796314825
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.9.23...235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... col 241220

123456789457189236689723154235971468874632591961548372312895647548267913796314825
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.9.23...235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... col 241220

123456789457189236689327145218643957374295618596718423731862594845971362962534871
1.3.5.78..57.8..3668....1.5.18....5.37....61.5.6.....373186.......9..........4... monh 241219
1.3.5.78..57.8..3668....1.5.18....5737....61.5.6.....373186.......9..........4... col 241220

123456789457189236689723145295638471371594628864271593548312967732965814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....29....4.13.1..462..64..1.93.4....96...2....149.6...3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....29....4.13.1..462..64..1.93.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145295638471374591628861274593548312967732965814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....29....4.13.4..162..61..4.93.4....96...2....149.6...3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....29....4.13.4..162..61..4.93.4....96..32....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689273154291865473735941862846327915374612598568794321912538647
1..4.678.4..18..366...731.4.9.......7.5......8..3.7......61...8...7.43.1....38.4. monh 241219
1..4.678.4..18..366...731.4.9.......7.5......8..3.7......61...8...7.43.1....3864. col 241220

123456789457189236689273451276815943315964827894732165548391672761528394932647518
12..56..9.571.9..66.927...1.......4.......8.7...7.2..55...91....6.52....9.26.7... monh 241219
12..56..9.571.9..66.927...1.......4.......8.7...7.2..55...91....6152....9.26.7... col 241220

123456789457189236698372415236715948841923567975648123319267854562894371784531692
12.....8..57...2.66......15...7..........356....64.12..1.2..85....8...7178.5..6.2 monh 241219
12....78..57...2.66.8....15...7..........356....64.12..1.2..85....8...7178.5..6.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689732514265347198391628457748915623534871962816294375972563841
1.3.56..9...1.9.366.973.51......719........57....156.3..4......8........97.563... monh 241219
1.3.567.9...1.9.366.973.51......719........57....156.3..4......8........97.563... col 241220

123456789457189236689723514278695341346871952591234867734512698815967423962348175
1...56....5718....68...3......6.5.41...8.19..........773.51...8....67..3.6.3.8..5 monh 241219
1.3.56....5718....68.7.3......6.5.41...8.19..........773.51...8....67..3.6.3.8..5 col 241220

123456789457189263698372541234695817519837624786241935372964158865713492941528376
1.3.56..9.571.9..369.37...1...6..8.7.......2.7.6.....5.7..6.....65.13...9.15..... monh 241219
1.3.56..9.571.9..369.37...1...6..8.7.......2.7.6.....537.96.....65.13...9.15..... col 241220

123456789457189263869327451238961574675234918914875326342518697586793142791642835
....56..9.5.1.92.....32..5123.961....7.........4......3..51.6..5...931.2...6.2.35 monh 241219
....56..9.5.1.926....32..5123.961....7.........4......3..51.69.5...931.2...6.2.35 col 241220

123456789457189236968372514236945871749218365815763942394821657572634198681597423
.23.5..8945..8.23.9.8...5.423....8...49...3.58.5....42.94.2.......6.........974.. monh 241219
.23.5..8945..8.23.9.8...5.423....8...49...3.58.5....42.94.2.......6.........974.. col 241220

123456789457189236968372514215648397346791852789235641592864173674513928831927465
.234...8945....23.9.83..5.42.5...39.34....8.2.89....4.5.28........51..2......7... monh 241219
.234...8945....23.9.83..5.42.5...39.34....8.2.89....4.5.28........51..2......7... col 241220

123456789457189236689372145296745318348621957571938624765813492834297561912564873
...4.67..4..18.2.6....72....96.......48621...5.1...6.....81.4.2..42.7.61..2.6487. monh 241219
...4.67..4..18.2.6....72....96.......48621...5.1...6.....81.4.2..42.7.61..2.6487. col 241220

123456789457189236698732514231975648749368125865241397386514972572893461914627853
..3.567.9..71.9.36......51..31.75....49......8.5.........51.97.....93.6....6..... monh 241219
..3.567.9..71.9.36...73.51..31975....49......8.5....9.3..51.97.....93.6....6.7... col 241220

123456789457189236968372154296738541741925863835614972312847695589263417674591328
1...567.9...1.9.369..37.15....7..5.1..19.5.63......97.31....69558.......6.45..... monh 241219
1...567.9...1.9.369..37.15....7..5.1..19.5.63......97.31....69558.......6.45..... col 241220

123456789457189236689723514215947863796835142834612957341298675562371498978564321
1.3.56.8..5718..3.68.7.3.1..15...863.....5..2......95.3.1..8...56..71..8.78...... monh 241219
1.3.56.8..5718..3.68.7.3.1..15...863.....5..2......95.3.1..8...56..71..8.78...... col 241220

123456789457189236869237514238671495514892673976345821395724168682513947741968352
1.34.6......18.......2.7...23.6..49..14...6.39.63...2139.......6.2...9...41...3.2 monh 241219
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...23.6..49..14...6.39.63...2139.......6.2...9...41.6.3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236869237514238671495541892673976345821395724168682513947714968352
1.34.6......18.......2.7...23.6..49..41...6.39.63...2139.......6.2...9...14.6.3.2 monh 241219
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...23.6..49..41...6.39.63...2139.......6.2...9...14.6.3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236698237514265814397341792658879563421516348972784925163932671845
12.......4.71.9.....8........5.1439....79..5....5.3...5..34.97.7..9.51.39...71.45 monh 241219
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.1439....79..5....5.3...5..34.97.7..9.51.39...71.45 col 241220

123456789457189236698237514265814397341792658879563421516378942784925163932641875
12.......4.71.9.....8........5.1439....79..5....5.3...5..37.94.7..9.51.39...41.75 monh 241219
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.1439....79..5....5.3...5..37.94.7..9.51.39...41.75 col 241220

123456789457189236698237514265814397341972658879563421516348972732691845984725163
12.......4.71.9.....8........5.1439....97..5....5.3...5..34.97.7...91.459..7.51.3 monh 241219
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.1439....97..5....5.3...5..34.97.7...91.459..7.51.3 col 241220

123456789457189236698237514265841397341792658879563421516378942784925163932614875
12.......4.71.9.....8........5.4139....79..5....5.3...5..37.94.7..9.51.39...14.75 monh 241219
12.......4571.9.....8....1...5.4139....79..5....5.3...5..37.94.7..9.51.39...14.75 col 241220

123456789457189236689732514268945173314267958975318462542673891796821345831594627
..34.6...4.7.89...68.73.....6894....3.4.679..97.3.84......7389.........5.......2. monh 241219
..34.6...4.7.89...68.73.....6894....3.4.679..97.3.84.....67389.........5.......2. col 241220

123456789456789123798231564275894316364175298819362457587913642632548971941627835
.2..567.9.5.7.9.23.9.23.56..7....3.6.64......8...........9.36.2...5..97.....2..35 monh 241219
.2..567.9.5.7.9.23.9.23.56..7....3.6.64......8...........9.36.2...5..97.....27.35 col 241220

123456789457189236689273451214367598536928174978541362365812947741695823892734615
....56...45..8.......2......14....9.53....1.49.8...3..3.5.1.94..41.9.8.389..3..15 monh 241219
....56...45..8.......2......14....9853....1.49.8...3..3.5.1.94..41.9.8.389..3..15 col 241220

123456789457189236689273451235841967794365812861927345312698574548712693976534128
....5..89...18.........3...2.5.4.96..94.6.8.286..2..45..2...5.4.4....69.9......28 monh 241219
....5..89...18.........3...2.5.4.96..94.6.8.286..2..45..2...5.454....69.9.6....28 col 241220

123456789457189236869273415246917853571638924938524167392761548614895372785342691
1.3.....945.....36.69..34...4.....535...3.9.493....16....7.....614.95........2... monh 241219
1.3.....945.....36.69..341..4.....535...3.9.493....16....7.....614.95........2... col 241220

123456789457189236689723415298534671514867923736912854371648592862395147945271368
...4.67....7..9.......2.....98....7151....9..7.6....5..71..859.86...51.79.5..1.68 monh 241219
...4.67....7..9.......2.....98....7151....9..7.6...85..71..859.86...51.79.5..1.68 col 241220

123456789457189236689723415298534671514867923736912854375648192862391547941275368
...4.67....7..9.......2.....98....7151....9..7.6....5..75..819.86...15.79.1..5.68 monh 241219
...4.67....7..9.......2.....98....7151....9..7.6...85..75..819.86...15.79.1..5.68 col 241220

123456789456789132789213654237195468694872315815364297378521946561947823942638571
12..567...567.91..7.921.6..2.71.5...69...2....15.6........2.94.........39.2...5.. monh 241219
12..567...567.91..7.921.6..2.71.5...69..72....15.6........2.94.........39.2...5.. col 241220

123456789456789132789231546297613458538924671614578293341867925875192364962345817
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.....1....53.9........5.8..334....92..75...3..9.2.....7 monh 241219
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.....1....53.9........5.8..334....92..75...3.49.2.....7 col 241220

123456789457189236698237514245793168361842975789615423536921847872564391914378652
12..56....57.8...66.8..7...2.57..1...618.2....8..15.2.....218.7......39.......... monh 241219
12..56....57.8...66.8..7...2.57..1...618.2...78..15.2.....218.7......39.......... col 241220

123456789457189236689372541291643857376598412845721963534917628762835194918264375
...4.6.....7.89.36...37..4...1......37..98...8.5....6....9.76.87..83..949...6437. monh 241219
...4.6.....7.89.36...37..4...1......37..98...8.5....6....9.76.87..83..949...6437. col 241220

123456789457189236689372541291643857376598412845721963534917628718264395962835174
...4.6.....7.89.36...37..4...1......37..98...8.5....6....9.76.87...6439.9..83..74 monh 241219
...4.6.....7.89.36...37..4...1......37..98...8.5....6....9.76.87...6439.9..83..74 col 241220

123456789457189263698372514281643975376598421945721836534817692719264358862935147
...4.6.....7.89.63...37...4..1......37..98...9.5.....6...8.769.7...643.88..93..47 monh 241219
...4.6.....7.89.63...37...4..1......37..98...9.5.....6...8.769.7...643.88..93..47 col 241220

123456789457189236698237415235891674714562893869743521341678952572914368986325147
.23.....94.7..9.3669..........8.1..47.4.62.......4....34..7.9.2.72...36.9.6.2..47 monh 241219
.23.....94.7..9.3669..........8.1..47.4.62.......4....34..7.9.2.72...36.9.6.2..47 col 241220

123456789457189263689372451271893645846517392935264178368941527514728936792635814
12....7.9.5.1..26.6......5127..9...5..6..7.929.5...17.....4.........8...79.6.5... monh 241219
12....7.9.5.1..26.6......5127..9.6.5..6..7.929.5...17.....4.........8...7926.5... col 241220

123456789457189236698327415271938654836245197945671328369814572514792863782563941
12....78..5.1..2.66......1527...86..8.6...1.7..5.7..28.....4.......9....78.56.... monh 241219
12....78..5.1..2.66......1527...865.8.6...1.7..5.7..28.....4.......9....78256.... col 241220

123456789457189236698237514274968351815374692936521847361842975542793168789615423
12..56....57.8...66.8..7.........3.........9.....218.7.618.2...5.27..1...8..15.2. monh 241219
12..56....57.8...66.8..7.........3.........9....5218.7.618.2...5.27..1..78..15.2. col 241220

123456789457189263689372451271893546846517392935264178368741925514928637792635814
12....7.9.5.1..26.6......5127..9.5....6..7.929.5...17.....4.........8...79.6.5... monh 241219
12....7.9.5.1..26.6......5127..9.5.6..6..7.929.5...17.....4.........8...7926.5... col 241220

123456789457189236698327415271938564836245197945671328369714852514892673782563941
12....78..5.1..2.66......1527...85..8.6...1.7..5.7..28.....4.......9....78.56.... monh 241219
12....78..5.1..2.66......1527...856.8.6...1.7..5.7..28.....4.......9....78256.... col 241220

123456789457189236698237514285374691714968352936521847361842975542793168879615423
12..56....57.8...66.8..7..........9.......3......218.7.618.2...5.27..1..8...15.2. monh 241219
12..56....57.8...66.8..7..........9.......3.....5218.7.618.2...5.27..1..87..15.2. col 241220

123456789457189236689327145271893564365742891894561327512934678746218953938675412
1.3.567...5718....68...71..........4365...8.1.......2.51..3....7.6.18....386.5.1. monh 241219
1.3.567...5718....68.3.71..........4365...8.1.......2.51..3....7.6.18....386.5.1. col 241220

123456789457189236689732415241397568375864192896215374534678921762941853918523647
.234....945...9...6.9.32...24.....6.3.5.64.9..962.5...534...92.......8..........7 monh 241219
.2345...945...9...6.9.32...24.39..6.3.5.64.9..962.5...534...92.......8..........7 col 241220

123456789456789132789213645298561473364827951571934826615348297837192564942675318
.2.4.6.8.4.6.89....8921..4.29..614...6482......19.4...........7...192.64......3.. monh 241219
12.4.6.8.4.6.89....8921..4.29..614...6482......19.4...........7...192.64......3.. col 241220

123456789457189236698732415275843961381697542946521873534918627719264358862375194
12..5.78..57.8.2.6..8....1527.8...61.81...5.2..6...87.....18627.....4......3..... monh 241219
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8....1527.8...61.81...5.2..6...87.....18627.....4......3..... col 241220

123456789456789132789213645271568394648932571935147826392671458567894213814325967
12.4.6...4.6.891....921.6..2.1.68....489.2..19..14...........5....89421.........7 monh 241219
12.4.6...4.6.891...8921.6..2.1.68....489.2..19..14...........5....89421.........7 col 241220

123456789457189236689723154295641378376298415814375962542817693738964521961532847
12..567...571.92..6.972.1..2.56.1....7.29.....1...5.........6.3...96.5...6.....4. monh 241219
12..567...571.92..6.972.1..2.56.1....7629.....1..75.........6.3...96.5...6.....4. col 241220

123456789457189263986327145241978356675234918839615427368742591514893672792561834
.23.5.......1..2......27...24.....56..5...9...39...42.36..4.59.5.4.9.6.2.92.6..34 monh 241219
.23.5.......1..2......27...24.....566.5...9...39...42.36..4.59.5.4.9.6.2.92.6..34 col 241220

123456789457189236689327541264538917591764823738912465345871692812695374976243158
1.3.56....571....668...7..1......9.........2.738....653.587.6..81.6.5....76..3... monh 241219
1.3.56....5718...668.3.7..1......9.........2.738....653.587.6..81.6.5....76..3... col 241220

123456789457189236698732154289371465315624978746598312574263891862917543931845627
...4.678......9.3....7....428.........5.....8.4..98....7..6389..6.9.7.43.3.84.6.7 monh 241219
...4.678.....89.36...73...428.........5.....8.4..98....7..6389..6.9.7.43.3.84.6.7 col 241220

123456789457189236698372514269748153534621978781593462342815697875964321916237845
1.3.5.....57....3669..7.51..697....353....97.7.1....6....8..........4...916.37... monh 241219
1.3.5.7.9.57....3669..7.51..697..1.353....97.7.1....6....8..........4...916.37... col 241220

123456789457189236689732145264375891395821674871964523548697312712543968936218457
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.4.75.9..9582..7.87.9.4.2..48.97.....25.....9....8... monh 241219
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.4.75.9..9582..7.87.9.4.2..48.97...7.254....9..2.8... col 241220

123456789457189236689732145268375491345921678791864523574698312836217954912543867
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.8.75.9..4592..7.79.8.4.2..74.98...8....7.....25..... monh 241219
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.8.75.9..4592..7.79.8.4.2..74.98...8..2.7...9.254.... col 241220

123456789457189236689732145291864573345971628768325491574698312836217954912543867
...45..8.4.......6......14.29.8.4.7..4597..2.7.8.25.9..74.98...8....7.....25..... monh 241219
...45..8.4.......6......14.29.8.4.7..4597..2.7.8.25.9..74.98...8..2.7...9.254.... col 241220

123456789457189236689732145236918457598674312714523968375891624841267593962345871
...45..8.4.......6......14.2....8....98.74...7.452.....7589..2.84.2.7.9.9.2.45.7. monh 241219
...45..8.4.......6......14.2..9.8....98.74...7.452.....7589..2.84.2.7.9.9.2.45.7. col 241220

123456789457189236689732145236817954578694312914523867395241678741968523862375491
...45..8.4.......6......14.2..8......78.94...9.452.....9524..7.74.9.8.2.8.2.75.9. monh 241219
...45..8.4.......6......14.2..8.7....78.94...9.452.....9524..7.74.9.8.2.8.2.75.9. col 241220

123456789457189236698372415281943657736215948945768123369821574572634891814597362
1.3..6....571.9...69.3...1...19.3..773..15...9.576.1.3........4......8.....597.6. monh 241219
1.3..6....571.9.3.69.3...1...19.3..773..15...9.576.1.3........4......8.....59736. col 241220

123456789457189236689372154261948573598763412734215968376524891812697345945831627
...4.678.4...8.2.668..72.54....485.....76.4.2..42.5..83.........1........45...627 monh 241219
...4.678.4...8.2.668..72.54....485....876.4.2..42.5..83.........1........45...627 col 241220

123456789457189236689273514235741698761928453948365172394512867576894321812637945
12..56....57..9...6.9.7....2.57.169..6192....9...651.....512..7......3.........4. monh 241219
12..56..9.57..9..66.9.7....2.57.169..6192....9...651.....512.67......3.........4. col 241220

123456789457189236986372154239748561548631927671295843392514678715863492864927315
..3.567.9..71.9.36..6...15.2.....5...4....9.7..1.9.......51.67.....63.9....9.73.5 monh 241219
..3.567.9..71.9.36..6...15.2.9...5...4....9.7..1.95......51.67.....63.9....9.73.5 col 241220

123456789457189236968237514296814375341675892875392461512768943689543127734921658
1..4..78.4.71....6..82...142.6814......6.5.......9.....12....4.68..4..277.4...... monh 241219
12.4..78.4.71..2.6.682...142.6814......6.5.......9..6..12....4.68..4..277.4...... col 241220

123456789457189236698732154276398541345671928981245367564927813712863495839514672
..3.567....71.9.36......15.2.6......3.5671....81....6....9.........63.9....51.67. monh 241219
..3.567.9..71.9.36...73.15.2.6......3.5671....81....6....9.7.......63.9..3.51.67. col 241220

123456789457189236689327145275631894364978512891245673536714928748592361912863457
.....6...4.718....6...27...27.6.1..4..4.78..28.124.......714.287.....3.1.......57 monh 241219
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...27.6.1..4.64.78..28.124.......714.287.....3.1.......57 col 241220

123456789457189236698723514264517398581934627739268451345871962872695143916342875
1....67.9.57..9...69...35...6....39.......6.773..6..51...8.1......6951.3....4.... monh 241219
1.3..67.9.57..9.3669...351..6....39.......6.773..6..51...8.1......6951.3.1..4.... col 241220

123456789457189236689327145246791358395268417718534692534972861871645923962813574
..3.5678...718..36...3.71..24.......39.....1.7.853........7..6..7.6........81.57. monh 241219
..3.5678...718..36...3.71.524.....5.395....1.7.853........7..6..7.6........81.57. col 241220

123456789457189236689327145216748593538961427794532618362815974871694352945273861
1...56....5718...668.3.7..5.1....59.......42....53.6.836.81.....7.6.........7..6. monh 241219
1.3.56....5718...668.3.7..5.1....593.3....42....53.6.836.81.....7.6.........7..6. col 241220

123456789457189236689732145214573968598624317736918452375891624841267593962345871
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.45......98.24...7....8....7589..2.84.2.7.9.9.2.45.7. monh 241219
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.457.....98.24...7..9.8....7589..2.84.2.7.9.9.2.45.7. col 241220

123456789457189236689732145268395471375241698941867523594628317736914852812573964
....5..8.4.......6......1..2.8.95.7..7524..9.94.8.7.2..94.28...7....4...8.257.... monh 241219
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.8.95.7..7524..9.94.8.7.2..94.28...7..9.4...8.257.... col 241220

123456789457189236689732145218573964594628317736914852375241698862395471941867523
....5..8.4.......6......1..2.857.....94.28...7....4....7524..9.8.2.95.7.94.8.7.2. monh 241219
...45..8.4.......6......14.2.857.....94.28...7..9.4....7524..9.8.2.95.7.94.8.7.2. col 241220

123456789457189263689372415234568971561947832978231654346725198712893546895614327
12..567.9.57...26.6.9.72..5.....8...5619.7.......3.......7..19.71....5.6.9.....27 monh 241219
12..567.9.57...26.6.9.72.15.....8...5619.7.......3.......7..19.71....5.6.9.....27 col 241220

123456789457189236689273415265891374314567928798342651576928143832614597941735862
..345..89....8923...92.34.5.6.........4....287.8..2......92..43.....459.....358.2 monh 241219
..345..89....8923...92.34.5.6.........4....287.8..2......92..43.....459.....358.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689273415265891374314567928798342651576938142832614597941725863
..345..89....8923...92.34.5.6.........4....287.8..2......93..42.....459.....258.. monh 241219
..345..89....8923...92.34.5.6.........4....287.8..2......93..42.....459.....258.3 col 241220

123456789457189236689327451245693817738214965916875342392541678574968123861732594
1.3.56.8..5718....68.3.7.5....6.381.......9..........23..5.1...57..68....6173.5.. monh 241219
1.3.56.8..5718....68.3.7.5....6.381.......9..........23..5.1...57..68....6173.5.. col 241220

123456789457189236896732154265971843738645912914328567382567491541293678679814325
....567.9.5.1.9.36.9.73.15.26..7......8.......1.....67...5.7.91....9367.....1.3.5 monh 241219
....567.9.5.1.9.36.9.73.15.26..7......8.......1.....67...5.7.91....9367.....1.3.5 col 241220

123456789457189236689327451248693517735214968916578342392841675561732894874965123
1.3.56.8..5718....68.3.7.5....6.351.......9..........23..8.1....6173.8..87..65... monh 241219
1.3.56.8..5718....68.3.7.5....6.351.......9..........23..8.1....6173.8..87..65... col 241220

123456789457189236698327145214638957736592814985741623369214578572863491841975362
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5....3..57...5..81....7.16.336....578..2.......4....... monh 241219
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..38.57...5..81....7.16.336....578..2.......4....... col 241220

123456789456789132789123546231968475578342691694517328312875964847691253965234817
.234.6...4.678...278..23..623..68....783.....6.4..7.........9..847...2.3.......1. monh 241219
.234.6...4.678...278..23..623..68....7834.6..6.4..7.........9..847...2.3.......1. col 241220

123456789456789123789132564238594671645371892917268345392617458564823917871945236
.2345.7..45.7.9...7.9.325..23...4....4537....9.72.....392...45........1.........6 monh 241219
.2345.7..45.7.9...7.9.325..23..94.7..4537....9.72.....392...45........1.........6 col 241220

123456789457189263869327415278964531396512874541738926685243197712695348934871652
.23....894.....2.38.9....1.2.8..4.3139...28.4.41..892......319....6.........71... monh 241219
.23....894.....2.38.9...41.2.8..4.3139...28.4.41..892......319....6.....9...71... col 241220

123456789456789132789213654214538976635971428897642513342197865561824397978365241
12..56..9.567.9..27.921....21.5.....6.5.7.....976.2.........8..561....97.......4. monh 241219
12..56..9.567.9..27.921....21.5.....6.5.71.2..976.2.........8..561....97.......4. col 241220

123456789456789123798213564234678915615932478879541632362195847541827396987364251
.23.5.78.45..8..237.8...5.4234.78......9..........1...3.2.....754....3...87...25. monh 241219
.23.5.78.45..8..237.8...5.4234.78......9..........1...3.2..5.4754....3...87...25. col 241220

123456789457189236698237415276543891541928367839761542382695174764312958915874623
12..56....5718...66..2.7..5.7.....91......3.7...7615.2.8.6.5...76..12......87.... monh 241219
12..56....5718...66.82.7..5.7.....91......3.7...7615.2.8.6.5...76..12.5....87.... col 241220

123456789457189236689327145275638914361974852894215673512863497748592361936741528
.....6...4.718....6...27...27.6.8..4..1.74..28.421...........977.....3.1...741.28 monh 241219
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...27.6.8..4.61.74..28.421...........977.....3.1...741.28 col 241220

123456789457189236689327145275638914364971852891245673512863497748592361936714528
.....6...4.718....6...27...27.6.8..4..4.71..28.124...........977.....3.1...714.28 monh 241219
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...27.6.8..4.64.71..28.124...........977.....3.1...714.28 col 241220

123456789457189236968732154289613547346875921571924368695241873734598612812367495
1.34.6....5.1......68.3........1.5.7.......2...1...3..6.5.418...345.86..81.36.4.. monh 241219
1.34.6...45.18.....68.3........1.5.7.......2.5.1...3..6.5.418...345.86..81.36.4.. col 241220

123456789457189236689327154214538697395764812768912543546873921832691475971245368
1.3.56....5718....68.3.71.........9.........2768...5.35.687...183.6.1....71..5... monh 241219
1.3.56....5718....68.3.71.........9.........2768...5.35.687...183.6.1....71..5... col 241220

123456789457189236689372415231768594764593821895241367348915672516827943972634158
.2.45..89.5..8923..8.3.24.5.31.....47.........9..4.......9.5..2...82.94.....34.58 monh 241219
.2.45..89.5..8923..8.3.24.5.31.....47.........9..4.......9.5..2...82.94.....34.58 col 241220

123456789456789123798213564274835916361924857985671432519367248642598371837142695
12.4.6.8.4.6.89.2..9821..6.2.48......61.24...9..6.1....19....4.......3.....1...95 monh 241219
12.4.6.8.4.6.89.2..9821..6.2.48......61.24...98.6.1....19....4.......3.....1...95 col 241220

123456789456789123789132564248375916615894372937261845362518497591647238874923651
.2.45..89.5..8912..8.1.25.4.4....9..61..9......7.........5.8.9.....4.2.8...92..51 monh 241219
.2.45..89.5..8912..8.1.25.4.4....91.61..9......7.........5.849.....4.2.8...92..51 col 241220

123456789456789123789132564248375916615894372937261845362918457591647238874523691
.2.45..89.5..8912..8.1.25.4.4....9..61..9......7.........9.8.5.....4.2.8...52..91 monh 241219
.2.45..89.5..8912..8.1.25.4.4....91.61..9......7.........9.845.....4.2.8...52..91 col 241220

123456789457189236689327514275963841391548627846712395512634978768291453934875162
....56.89...1.9..6....2.51...596.8.1..15.862...6.12.95..2...9..7.8.9.....3....... monh 241219
....56.89...1.92.6....2.51...596.8.1..15.862...6.12.95..2...9.87.8.9.....3....... col 241220

123456789456789123897231645215697438369814257784523916541968372678342591932175864
1.3...789.......23....3..45.15.97..83.981...778.5.3...5.1....7..78......93..758.. monh 241219
1.3...789.......23....3..45.15.97..83.981...778.5.3...5.1....7..78......93..758.. col 241220

123456789456789132789132564245617398631895427978324651314968275597243816862571943
123...7.9.56..9....89......2..6.739........27.7....6.1...96.27...72.3.16..2.719.3 monh 241219
123...7.9.56..9....89......2..6.739........27.7....6.1...96.27...72.3.16..2.719.3 col 241220

123456789457189236689723541234567198578931624961842357396218475742695813815374962
..3.5678...718..36...7.35.12.........78.31...9.1....5.3...18.757..6.5......37..6. monh 241219
..3.5678...718..36...7.35.12.........78.31...9.1....5.3...18.757..6.5......37..6. col 241220

123456789456789132789231546218975463675843921934162857342597618567318294891624375
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.573..5.....5..318.......24375 monh 241219
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.573..5.....5..318.......24375 col 241220

123456789456789132789231546218975463675843921934162857367518294542397618891624375
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.573..518...5..3.........24375 monh 241219
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.573..518...5..3.........24375 col 241220

123456789456789132789231546218975463675843921934162875342597618567318294891624357
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.753..5.....5..318.......24357 monh 241219
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.753..5.....5..318.......24357 col 241220

123456789456789132789231546218975463675843921934162875367518294542397618891624357
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.753..518...5..3.........24357 monh 241219
.234..7.945.7...327.92..54.2.....4.3......92.93...2.753..518...5..3.........24357 col 241220

123456789456789123798213564237648915645971238819532647364195872571824396982367451
.23.5.78.45..8..237.8...5.4237.48......9.1............3.4..5..257....3...82....5. monh 241219
.23.5.78.45..8..237.8...5.4237.48......9.1............3.4..5.7257....3...82...45. col 241220

123456789457189236689327415214978653378564921596213847742631598835792164961845372
1.3.....945.....3..89...4...14..8.533.8..49.159...384....6.1.9....7.....9.1..5... monh 241219
1.3....8945.....3..89...4.5.14..8.533.8..49.159...384....6.1.9....7.....9.1..5... col 241220

123456789457189236689327415218974653374568921596213847742631598835792164961845372
1.3.....945.....3..89...4...18..4.533.4..89.159...384....6.1.9....7.....9.1..5... monh 241219
1.3....8945.....3..89...4.5.18..4.533.4..89.159...384....6.1.9....7.....9.1..5... col 241220

123456789457189236698372154215964873784513962936728541341895627569247318872631495
1.3..67.9.57..9.3669....15........737.....96.93.7..5.13....5...5.924.......6.1.95 monh 241219
1.3..67.9.57..9.3669....15........737.....96.93.7..5.13....5...5.924.......6.1.95 col 241220

123456789457189236698372154265741893341968572789523641576294318814637925932815467
1.3.5.7.9.57....3669..7.15..657.1.93..1...57....5..6.1..629........379.5...8..... monh 241219
1.3.5.7.9.57....3669..7.15..657.1.93..1...57....5..6.1..629........379.5...8..... col 241220

123456789457189236896723514214835967638947125975612348381574692562398471749261853
1.34.6.......8........235...14...9..63.94.1.59.5.1....3.1..469.56....4.1.49..1.53 monh 241219
1.34.6.......8........235...14...9..63.94.1.59.5.1....3.1..469.56....4.1.49..1.53 col 241220

123456789457189236689237541276348195538921467941765823395872614712694358864513972
...45........89.....92.7.4.2...48.955..92.4.79..7.582..95872...71.......86.....7. monh 241219
...45........89.....92.7.4.2...48.955..92.4.79..7.582..95872...71.......86.....7. col 241220

123456789457189236689237541241765893538921467976348125395872614712694358864513972
...45........89.....92.7.4.2..7.589.5..92.4.79...48.25.95872...71.......86.....7. monh 241219
...45........89.....92.7.4.2..7.589.5..92.4.79...48.25.95872...71.......86.....7. col 241220

123456789456789132789213654235871946861942573947365218372198465518624397694537821
1..45.7.94..7.913.....13.54....719.....94..73..73.5.1.3.2......5.8...3.....53.... monh 241219
1..45.7.94..7.913.....13.54....719.....94..73..73.5.1.3.2......5.8...3.....53.... col 241220

123456789457189236698372514245917368379864152816235497532648971764591823981723645
1.3.5....45.1.9....983...1..4591.3..3.98.4...81..354........97.....9.82.98....... monh 241219
1.3.5....45.1.9....983...1..4591.3..3.98.4...81..354........97.....9.82.98....... col 241220

123456789457189236698237541219863475374915862586724193731598624862341957945672318
.....678.4.....23...........1.86......4.158..58.7.4...7.15.8...86..41..7.4567...8 monh 241219
....5678.4.....23...........1.86......4.158..58.7.4...7.15.8...86..41..7.4567...8 col 241220

123456789456789231789123645214567398375891462968342157532974816691238574847615923
.23...7.945...923.7.9..3.452.4...39..75.9.4.29......57..2..........3.5.4...61.... monh 241219
.23...7.945...923.7.9..3.452.4...39..75.9.4.29......57..2..........3.5.4..761.... col 241220

123456789457189236869372514281593647635247891974618352342965178598721463716834925
.23.5..8945..8.23.8.9...5.428.....4..35...89.9.4..83.23.2..5......7.1.........9.. monh 241219
.23.5..8945..8.23.8.9...5.428.....4..35...89.9.4..83.23.2..5......7.14........9.. col 241220

123456789457189236698732415246973158539841672871625943364218597782594361915367824
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8....15...9.3......8...72..1.......6....5.77.25...61.15...82. monh 241219
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8....15..69.3......8...72..1.......6....5.77.25...61.15...82. col 241220

123456789457189236689327514241938675395672148876541392514293867732864951968715423
1...56....5.18...668.3.7.....1.38.7.3.567....87.5..3...........73.....51......42. monh 241219
1...56....5.18...668.3.7.....1.38.7.3.567....87.5.13...........73.....51......42. col 241220

123456789457189236689723154245938671391672548876541392514297863732864915968315427
1...56....5.18...668.7.3.....5.38.7.3.167....87...13...........73.....15......42. monh 241219
1...56....5.18...668.7.3.....5.38.7.3.167....87.5.13...........73.....15......42. col 241220

123456789457189236689327154216743895534892617798615342342978561871564923965231478
1.3.56....57.8...668...7....167.3...53.8...1.7...153.................92.....31.78 monh 241219
1.3.56....57.8...668...7....167.3...53.8...1.7.8.153.................92.....31.78 col 241220

123456789457189263896237154289645317571823496634971825315798642762514938948362571
1..4.678.4..18..638...371.4...64..17...8.34.6....718..3.5...6....2.........36.... monh 241219
1..4.678.4..18..638...371.4...64..17...8.34.6....718..3.5...6....2.........36.... col 241220

123456789456789132789123546237568914615294378948371625362815497574932861891647253
.2.45.7.9.5.7.9.32....2354....5..9.4..5.9437....37..25..2...497.........8.1...... monh 241219
.2.45.7.9.5.7.9.32....2354....5..9.4..5.9437....37..25..2...497.........8.1...... col 241220

123456789457189236689327541218974365395862174764531928571248693836795412942613857
1.3.56.8..5718..3.68.3.7....18.7....3.586....76.5.1..8571.....3......4.2......... monh 241219
1.3.56.8..5718..3.68.3.7....18.7....3.586....76.5.1..8571.....3......4.2......... col 241220

123456789457189263689723451245638917736912845891574326374261598562897134918345672
1.3...78..57...2.3.8.....51...6......3.9.2.........32.37...15.85.2..713..18..5.72 monh 241219
1.3...78..57...2.3.8.....51...6......3.9.2.........32.37...15.85.2..713..18..5.72 col 241220

123456789457189326689327451241975863736841295895632147364518972578293614912764538
1.3.567...5718.3..68.3.7.....1.75......8.1...8.563...7........2..8...6.4...76.53. monh 241219
1.3.567...5718.3..68.3.7.....1.75......8.1...8.563...7........2..8...6.4...76.53. col 241220

123456789457189236698237415235891647714562893869743521341678952572914368986325174
.23.....94.7..9.3669..........8.1..77.4.62.......4....34..7.9.2.72...36.9.6.2..74 monh 241219
.23.....94.7..9.3669..........8.1..77.4.62.......4....34..7.9.2.72...36.9.6.2..74 col 241220

123456789457189236698237514245973168361842975789615423514768392872394651936521847
12..56....57.8...66.8..7...2.5.7.1...618.2....8..15.2.......39..............218.7 monh 241219
12..56....57.8...66.8..7...2.5.7.1...618.2...78..15.2.......39.............5218.7 col 241220

123456789456789123789132564271594836648321957935678412392845671517963248864217395
.234.6...4.678...378..32..4...............95....6784.23..84......7.63...86.2.73.. monh 241219
.234.6...4.678...378..32..4...............95....6784.23.284......7.63...86.2.73.. col 241220

123456789457189236689273145216897453594361827738542691341725968865914372972638514
.23.5....45...9...6.92.....2.6...4..........7.....26.134..259...659.43..9.263.5.. monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.92.3...2.6...4..........7.....26.134..259...659.43..9.263.5.. col 241220

123456789457189236698732514271564398835291647946378125389627451564913872712845963
12..56.8..5718....6.87.2.1.27.56...88..2.1.....6.78......627.51...............9.3 monh 241219
12..56.8..5718....6.87.2.1.27.56...88.52.1.....6.78......627.51...............9.3 col 241220

123456789457189236689732154268913547534267891971845623395621478746598312812374965
...4.678.....89.3....73...4.6.9.3.47.3..6789..7.84.6.3.95.....8.4..98.....2...... monh 241219
...4.678.....89.36...73...4.6.9.3.47.3..6789..7.84.6.3.95.....8.4..98.....2...... col 241220

123456789457189236689732154268917543574263891931845627395621478746598312812374965
...4.678.....89.3....73...4.6.9.7.43.7..6389..3.84.6.7.95.....8.4..98.....2...... monh 241219
...4.678.....89.36...73...4.6.9.7.43.7..6389..3.84.6.7.95.....8.4..98.....2...... col 241220

123456789457189236968237154239578461581624973746391825395742618674815392812963547
1......89...18..3.........423..78.6..8162..7.7.63.1.2.3..7.2....7.81.....12.63... monh 241219
1......89...18..3.........423..78.6..8162..7.7.63.1.2.3..7.2...67.81.....12.63... col 241220

123456789457189236968237154246391875581674923739528461395742618674815392812963547
1......89...18..3.........42.63.1.7..8167..2.73..28.6.3..7.2....7.81.....12.63... monh 241219
1......89...18..3.........42.63.1.7..8167..2.73..28.6.3..7.2...67.81.....12.63... col 241220

123456789457189236896273154289745361641398527735612948372964815514837692968521473
...4...89....8923......31.4..9.....16.13.....7..........29.481...483..92..8.214.3 monh 241219
...4...89....8923....2.31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...483..92..8.214.3 col 241220

123456789457189236896273154289745361641398527735612948372964815514827693968531472
...4...89....8923......31.4..9.....16.13.....7..........29.481...482..93..8.314.2 monh 241219
...4...89....8923....2.31.4..9...3.16.13.....7..........29.481...482..93..8.314.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689372451261897543795243168834615972348721695516934827972568314
1.....7.9...18923.......4.12.189...3.952.3..883..15..23...2....51.93.82....5..3.. monh 241219
1.....7.9...18923.......4.12.189...3.952.3..883..15..23...2....51.93.82....5..3.. col 241220

123456789457189236689372451265897143791243568834615972348721695516934827972568314
......7.9...18923.......4.12.589...3.9.2.3..883..15..23...2....51.93.82....5..3.. monh 241219
1.....7.9...18923.......4.12.589...3.912.3..883..15..23...2....51.93.82....5..3.. col 241220

123456789457189236689372451234615978791843562865297143348721695516934827972568314
......7.9...18923.......4.123..15..8.9.8.3..28.529...33...2....51.93.82....5..3.. monh 241219
1.....7.9...18923.......4.123..15..8.918.3..28.529...33...2....51.93.82....5..3.. col 241220

123456789457189236689372451234615978795843162861297543348721695516934827972568314
......7.9...189.3.......4.123..15..8.958.3...8..29...33...2....51.93.82....5..3.. monh 241219
1.....7.9...18923.......4.123..15..8.958.3..28.129...33...2....51.93.82....5..3.. col 241220

123456789456789123789123564231567948548391672967842315375214896612938457894675231
.2345...945.7.9...7.9.23..4...5.7.........6....7....1537.2.4.....293.....94.752.. monh 241219
.2345...945.7.9..37.9.23..4...5.7.........6....7....1537.2.4.....293.....94.75... col 241220

123456789457189263689723145271564938365978412894231657546392871712845396938617524
12...6.89.5....26.6.9...1.52.1...9.8.659...1289.2..65.......8.1.1.84.........7... monh 241219
12.....89.5....26.6.9...1.52.15..9.8.659...1289.2..65.......8.1.1.84.........7... col 241220

123456789457189236698327415289613547376542891541978362732891654814765923965234178
12..5.78..57...2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.2..165.81.....2..65...1.8 monh 241219
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.2...65.81.....2..65...1.8 col 241220

123456789457189236689372415291837564346925178875641392532798641718564923964213857
1.3.5..8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.53...8.41.18...9.39.4..385. monh 241219
1.3....8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.53...8.41.18..49.39.4..385. col 241220

123456789457189236689372415291837564346925178875641392512798643738564921964213857
1.3.5..8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.51...8.43.38...9.19.4..385. monh 241219
1.3....8945.....3..89...4.5.91..........2.......6.1.9.51...8.43.38..49.19.4..385. col 241220

123456789456789132789213645294671358367895214518342967635928471872134596941567823
12...6.894.6..91.2.89...64.....7........9.21...83.....6.....4.18.2....96.41.6.82. monh 241219
12...6.894.6..91.2.89...64.....7........9.214...3.....6.....4.18.2....96.41.6.82. col 241220

123456789456789132789123546268947351314562897975831264597314628631298475842675913
.23...7.945...9.327.9..354.2.....35.3.4....97.75.3.2.4..7.1........9.4.5..26..... monh 241219
.23...7.945...9.327.9..354.2.....35.3.4....97.75.3.2.4....1........9.475...6..... col 241220

123456789457189236689372514241967853836541972975823461314795628568214397792638145
.2345....45...9...6.93.25........8...36...........3.613.4.95.2.56.2.4.9..9263.... monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.93.2.........8...36...........3.613.4.95.2.56.2.4.9..9263..4. col 241220

123456789457189236698327415289613547376245198541978362735891624814762953962534871
12..5.78..57...2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.5..162.81.....5..62...8.1 monh 241219
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8.2..15.....3....76.........97..6.7.5...62.81.....5..62...8.1 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145271534968395268471864971523548312697732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..496.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....69...2....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145274531968395268471861974523548312697732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..196.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....69...2....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145271534698395268471864971523548312967732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.1..469.39....4.1.64..1.23.4....96...2....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236689723145274531698395268471861974523548312967732695814916847352
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96...2....149.....3.2 monh 241219
....5.......1.9236...7.....2.4..169.39....4.1.61..4.23.4....96...2....149.6...3.2 col 241220

123456789457189236968372154289735461374621598615894327542918673796543812831267945
.2....78.4.....2.6..8....5428.7..46..746..5.86.58...27....1.......5.3......2...45 monh 241219
.2....78.4.....2.6.68....5428.7..46..746..5.86.58...27....1.......5.3......2...45 col 241220

123456789457189236689723154235971468874632591961548372312895647548267913796314825
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.956..54.26.9...963.4... col 241220

123456789457189236689723154235971468874632591961548372312865947548297613796314825
.234.....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... monh 241219
.2345....45...9...6.9.2....235...46.........1.......7.3.2.659..54.29.6...963.4... col 241220

123456789457189236698372154269547813531928647784613925312765498875294361946831572
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7......75.9....9.6..1... monh 241219
1.3.56..9.571.9..669.37..........8..531...6.7.......2.31.7.5....75.9....9.6.31... col 241220

123456789457189236689327145294815673361972854875634912518263497742598361936741528
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...2.481......1.72..487.6.4..2.......977.....3.1...741.28 col 241015
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...2.481.....61.72..487.6.4..2.......977.....3.1...741.28 col 241220

123456789457189236689327145296745318348261957571938624765813492834692571912574863
...4.67..4..18.2.6....27....96.......48261...5.1...6.....81.4.2..46.2..1..2.7486. col 241015
...4.67..4..18.2.6....27....96.......48261...5.1...6.....81.4.2..46.2.71..2.7486. col 241220

123456789457189236689327145294815673361974852875632914518263497742598361936741528
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...2.481......1.74..287.6.2..4.......977.....3.1...741.28 col 241015
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...2.481.....61.74..287.6.2..4.......977.....3.1...741.28 col 241220

123456789457189236689327145296745318348261957571938624765813492832694571914572863
...4.67..4..18.2.6....27....96.......48261...5.1...6.....81.4.2..26.4..1..4.7286. col 241015
...4.67..4..18.2.6....27....96.......48261...5.1...6.....81.4.2..26.4.71..4.7286. col 241220

123456789457189236689372145294815673361927854875634912518263497742598361936741528
...4.6...4.718.2..6...72...2.481......1.27..487.6.4..2.......977.....3.1...741.28 col 241015
...4.6...4.718.2..6...72...2.481.....61.27..487.6.4..2.......977.....3.1...741.28 col 241220

123456789457189236869237514276345891398671425514892673682513947741968352935724168
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...2.63....139.6..42..14...6.36.2...9...41.6.3.293....... col 241015
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...2.63...9139.6..42..14...6.36.2...9...41.6.3.293....... col 241220

123456789457189236689327145291845673364971852875632914518263497742598361936714528
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...2.184......4.71..287.6.2..4.......977.....3.1...714.28 col 241015
...4.6...4.718.2..6...27...2.184.....64.71..287.6.2..4.......977.....3.1...714.28 col 241220

123456789457189236869237514286513947395724168714968352541892673672345891938671425
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...2.6...9..39........14.6.3.2.41...6.36.23....193.6..42. col 241015
1234.6......18.2.....2.7...2.6...9..39........14.6.3.2.41...6.36.23...9193.6..42. col 241220

123456789457189236689372145296745318348261957571938624765813492832694571914527863
...4.67..4..18.2.6....72....96.......48261...5.1...6.....81.4.2..26.4..1..4.2786. col 241015
...4.67..4..18.2.6....72....96.......48261...5.1...6.....81.4.2..26.4.71..4.2786. col 241220

123456789457189236698732514276541398345928671981367425562813947714295863839674152
..3.567.9..71...36...73.51.2.6......3.5...671.81.6..........9.7....9..63.3.67.15. col 241015
..3.567.9..71.9.36...73.51.2.6......3.5...671.81.6..........9.7....9..63.3.67.15. col 241220

123456789457189236689372514216798453348215697975643128561837942734921865892564371
..3.567.9..71.9.36..937.51.2.6.......4....6..9756.3.......379.....9......9.56.3.1 col 241015
..3.567.9..71.9.36..937.51.2.6.......4....6..9756.3.......379.....9.1....9.56.3.1 col 241220

123456789457189236698723415219548673385617942746392158532971864874265391961834527
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8.2..152.........85.....27.6..21.8...97....87.265........4..7 col 241015
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8.2..1521........85.....27.6..21.8...97....87.265........4..7 col 241220

123456789457189236869372514281593647635247891974618352342965178598721463716834925
.23.5..8945..8.23.8.9...5.428.....4..35...89.9.4..83.23.2..5......7.1.........9.. monh 241219
.23.5..8945..8.23.8.9...5.428.....4..35...89.9.4..83.2342..5......7.1............ col 241220

123456789457189236698732415246973158539841672871625943364218597782594361915367824
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8....15...9.3......8...72..1.......6....5.77.25...61.15...82. monh 241219
12..5.78..57.8.2.66.8....15...9.3......8..672..........6....5.77.25...61.15...82. col 241220

123456789456789231789123645214567398375891462968342157532974816691238574847615923
.23...7.945...923.7.9..3.452.4...39..75.9.4.29......57..2..........3.5.4...61.... monh 241219
.23...7.945...923.7.9..3.452.4...39..75.9.4.29......57.............3.574...61.... col 241220


different ratings
123456789457189236698327145214673958786592314935841627342765891571938462869214573
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..7..58...5..31......16.7.42...............86....573 8 monh 241219
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..73.58...5..31....8.16.7.42...............86....573 9 col 241220
123456789457189236698723154239645871746218593815937462382594617571362948964871325
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....82...61.5.1...9.896.8...25 8 monh 2412219
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....825..61.5.1...9.896.8...25 9 col 241220
hendrik_monard
 
Posts: 107
Joined: 19 April 2021
Location: Leuven (Louvain) Belgium
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby denis_berthier » Sun Dec 22, 2024 3:33 pm

hendrik_monard wrote:different ratings
123456789457189236698327145214673958786592314935841627342765891571938462869214573
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..7..58...5..31......16.7.42...............86....573 8 monh 241219
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..73.58...5..31....8.16.7.42...............86....573 9 col 241220
123456789457189236698723154239645871746218593815937462382594617571362948964871325
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....82...61.5.1...9.896.8...25 8 monh 2412219
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....825..61.5.1...9.896.8...25 9 col 241220[/hidden]

Not really. See my previous post. The four classifs are 8.
denis_berthier
2010 Supporter
 
Posts: 4275
Joined: 19 June 2007
Location: Paris
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby hendrik_monard » Sun Dec 22, 2024 3:38 pm

denis_berthier wrote:
coloin wrote:
hendrik_monard wrote:I also found two cases of different BxB rating within the BXB7+ domain for the same solution.

I think all these puzzles are BxB 8 ... so possibly a typo [ Usually SHC is consistent]

I think what Hendrik means is, for some solution grid, there are different non-isomorphic B7B+ puzzles with different BxB ratings - which is to be expected.
What I find more surprising is, this seems to be rare. Hendrik, can you say more about this ?
.

I am almost certain that the rare cases encountered until now are more likely to be due to 'typos'. I cannot recall any specific case of puzzles with the same solution but different B7B+ ratings. To draw a definitive conclusion on this, larger numbers of new grids would have to be investigated.
hendrik_monard
 
Posts: 107
Joined: 19 April 2021
Location: Leuven (Louvain) Belgium
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby hendrik_monard » Sun Dec 22, 2024 3:48 pm

denis_berthier wrote:
hendrik_monard wrote:different ratings
123456789457189236698327145214673958786592314935841627342765891571938462869214573
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..7..58...5..31......16.7.42...............86....573 8 monh 241219
1...5678....18..366..3.71.5.1..73.58...5..31....8.16.7.42...............86....573 9 col 241220
123456789457189236698723154239645871746218593815937462382594617571362948964871325
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....82...61.5.1...9.896.8...25 8 monh 2412219
12..56.89.5....2.6......15.....4.......2.859..1.93.....825..61.5.1...9.896.8...25 9 col 241220[/hidden]

Not really. See my previous post. The four classifs are 8.

Of course. But in this case these puzzles ended up there in the list because they are duplicates with regard to their solutions, regardless of their ratings.
This list was necessarily based on informations dating from before your correct finding that they have in fact the same rating
hendrik_monard
 
Posts: 107
Joined: 19 April 2021
Location: Leuven (Louvain) Belgium
Top

Re: The BxB classification of T&E(2) puzzles

Postby hendrik_monard » Sun Dec 22, 2024 4:42 pm

Some second thoughts about different BxB ratings for a given solution. There are now a large number of minimals of non minimal B7B+ puzzles available. Has someone tested if among those minimals there are some with different BxB ratings? I imagine that this could be the case for 'higher' expansions. Or is this theoretically impossible?
I can imagine that some 'higher' expansion has a lower BxB rating. In that case you would have different BxB rating for the same solution. Or must the search be limited to minimal puzzles or min_expands?
hendrik_monard
 
Posts: 107
Joined: 19 April 2021
Location: Leuven (Louvain) Belgium
Top
PreviousNext
Post a reply

Return to General

Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group

phpBB SEO