August 21, 2018 technique

Post the puzzle or solving technique that's causing you trouble and someone will help

August 21, 2018 technique

Postby rjamil » Tue Aug 21, 2018 7:25 pm

Hi,

While I was checking today's puzzle in HoDoKu, out of so many other next moves, found four XY-Chain moves containing exactly four bi-value cells as follows:
Code: Select all
.........6..7..5.9.8954..7.2....1.57...374...76.2....3.7..9823.8.6..2..4.........
 +------------------+---------+---------------+
 | 135   1235  7    | 8  12 9 | 1346 146 16   |
 | 6     124   124  | 7  12 3 | 5    8   9    |
 | 13    8     9    | 5  4  6 | 13   7   2    |
 +------------------+---------+---------------+
 | 2    (34)   348  | 9  6  1 | 48   5   7    |
 | 159   159   158  | 3  7  4 | 168  2   168  |
 | 7     6    (14)  | 2  8  5 | 9    14  3    |
 +------------------+---------+---------------+
 | 145   7    (15)  | 46 9  8 | 2    3   156  |
 | 8    (35)   6    | 1  35 2 | 7    9   4    |
 | 13459 12359 1235 | 46 35 7 | 168  16  1568 |
 +------------------+---------+---------------+

1) XY-Chain: 5 5- r7c3 -1- r6c3 -4- r4c2 -3- r8c2 -5 => r79c1,r9c23<>5
2) XY-Chain: 1 1- r6c3 -4- r4c2 -3- r8c2 -5- r7c3 -1 => r259c3<>1
3) XY-Chain: 3 3- r4c2 -4- r6c3 -1- r7c3 -5- r8c2 -3 => r19c2<>3
4) XY-Chain: 4 4- r4c2 -3- r8c2 -5- r7c3 -1- r6c3 -4 => r4c3<>4

Where as following ALS-XZ rule eliminates combined above four XY-Chains:
Almost Locked Set XZ-Rule: A=r4c2,r6c3 {134}, B=r7c3,r8c2 {135}, X=1,3 => r19c2<>3, r259c3<>1, r4c3<>4, r79c1,r9c23<>5

I think BarnS=4 (WXYZ-Wings) will also cover the same. Am I right?

R. Jamil
rjamil
 
Posts: 234
Joined: 15 October 2014
Location: Karachi, Pakistan

Re: August 21, 2018 technique

Postby SpAce » Wed Aug 22, 2018 10:32 pm

rjamil wrote:1) XY-Chain: 5 5- r7c3 -1- r6c3 -4- r4c2 -3- r8c2 -5 => r79c1,r9c23<>5
2) XY-Chain: 1 1- r6c3 -4- r4c2 -3- r8c2 -5- r7c3 -1 => r259c3<>1
3) XY-Chain: 3 3- r4c2 -4- r6c3 -1- r7c3 -5- r8c2 -3 => r19c2<>3
4) XY-Chain: 4 4- r4c2 -3- r8c2 -5- r7c3 -1- r6c3 -4 => r4c3<>4

Where as following ALS-XZ rule eliminates combined above four XY-Chains:
Almost Locked Set XZ-Rule: A=r4c2,r6c3 {134}, B=r7c3,r8c2 {135}, X=1,3 => r19c2<>3, r259c3<>1, r4c3<>4, r79c1,r9c23<>5

I think BarnS=4 (WXYZ-Wings) will also cover the same. Am I right?

I think you might get different answers from different people, as definitions seem to vary. To me it's easiest to see as:

XY-Loop: (3=4)r4c2 - (4=1)r6c3 - (1=5)r7c3 - (5=3)r8c2 - loop => -4 r4c3, -1 r259c3, -5 b7p1789, -3 r19c2

Your doubly-linked ALS XZ works too, although I hate the name. As an ALS move, I'd rather call it:

ALS-Loop: (3={4}1)b4p29 - (1{5}=3)b7p35 - loop => same eliminations

Of course that's just one way to express it, as the ALSs can be seen either in the boxes or the columns. These work just the same:

(4={1}5)r67c3 - (5={3}4)r84c2 - loop

(1={5}3)b7p35 - (3={4}1)b4p29 - loop

(5={1}4)r76c3 - (4={3}5)r48c2 - loop

By StrmCkr's definitions it's a Barn, I think, but not by John Welch's (his BARN doesn't cover fully restricted cases, as far as I understand). By StrmCkr's definitions it's probably a WXYZ-Wing as well, but not by Andrew Stuart's (loops not covered) or John Welch's (only the most classic case covered). So, I guess it's up to you. (I don't see it as either kind, but my opinion doesn't count.)

I think it's definitely a DDS, though: 4 cells, 4 digits, 4 sectors, each digit restricted to 1 sector.
Last edited by SpAce on Wed Aug 22, 2018 11:06 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Code: Select all
   *             |    |               |    |    *
        *        |=()=|    /  _  \    |=()=|               *
            *    |    |   |-=( )=-|   |    |      *
     *                     \  ¯  /                   *   
SpAce
 
Posts: 506
Joined: 22 May 2017

Re: August 21, 2018 technique

Postby ArkieTech » Wed Aug 22, 2018 11:04 pm

SpAce wrote:I think you might get different answers from different people


Makes life interesting 8-) I like it. :D
dan
User avatar
ArkieTech
 
Posts: 2955
Joined: 29 May 2006
Location: NW Arkansas USA

Re: August 21, 2018 technique

Postby SpAce » Wed Aug 22, 2018 11:12 pm

ArkieTech wrote:
SpAce wrote:I think you might get different answers from different people

Makes life interesting 8-) I like it. :D

Yeah, it does :mrgreen: Too bad it sometimes makes communication rather "interesting" as well, when people use different definitions without realizing it :shock:
Code: Select all
   *             |    |               |    |    *
        *        |=()=|    /  _  \    |=()=|               *
            *    |    |   |-=( )=-|   |    |      *
     *                     \  ¯  /                   *   
SpAce
 
Posts: 506
Joined: 22 May 2017

Re: August 21, 2018 technique

Postby rjamil » Thu Aug 23, 2018 4:08 pm

Hi all,

Many thanks for your valuable comments.

I will definitely go with WXYZ-Wings move as now, after analysing all aspacts in this post, it supersedes most of the techniques and easy to merge under one label.

I am still analysing all aspacts of the same and under finalizing paper work.

R. Jamil
rjamil
 
Posts: 234
Joined: 15 October 2014
Location: Karachi, Pakistan

Re: August 21, 2018 technique

Postby StrmCkr » Fri Aug 24, 2018 4:45 am

Barn size 4, aka Wxyz wing(my version) , or als xz double linked.. Sue du coq aka Dds (size 2)
Either way all the same elims s in the end, many techniques and names overlap personal preference for deffintion and eliminations are all over the place.

Others can find it, but takes 2 versions of Andrews /John's wxyz wings plus box line reduction afterwards to hit all the same eliminations. But each their own.

Cheers.
Some do, some teach, the rest look it up.
User avatar
StrmCkr
 
Posts: 840
Joined: 05 September 2006


Return to Help with puzzles and solving techniques